Brandon Ketchum: The Marine Who Asked to Be Admitted, and the Law His Mother Carried
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Brandon Ketchum did the thing the system asks a veteran in crisis to do. On July 7, 2016, he went to the Iowa City VA Medical Center and asked, in person, to be admitted to its inpatient psychiatric unit. He was not admitted. Early the next morning he posted his rejection on Facebook, in his own words, and on July 8, 2016, he died by suicide at home. He was thirty-three. This page is the documented record of his service, of that last request and the answer it received, of what the VA's own inspector general found, and of what his mother, Beverly Kittoe, helped force into law in his name — told in dates, findings, and the institution's own words.
The service, and the promise
Brandon Ketchum served in two branches, in two wars. He was a sergeant in the U.S. Marine Corps, with two tours in Iraq, and he later served in Afghanistan with the Iowa Army National Guard. On the House floor on May 17, 2021, Rep. Cindy Axne of Iowa put one measure of that service on the record: in his first tour alone, Ketchum helped clear 92 roadside bombs in seven months, service that earned him the Combat Action Ribbon. He came home from his third deployment in 2010 after an injury, and, as the Des Moines Register’s profile of him documented, he struggled afterward to hold jobs, schooling, and relationships. He spoke publicly about it — to students, in 2014, among others — describing how his comfort zone had been, in his words, “being behind a rifle or being in a big armored vehicle,” and how ordinary life at home sat well outside it. In private notes quoted in that profile, he called what he was living “a war within myself.”
He lived in the Quad Cities — Davenport and Bettendorf, Iowa — and sought his care at the Iowa City VA Medical Center, where the record shows extensive treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, and addiction. The promise made to a veteran in that system is plain: when you cannot keep yourself safe, come in, and the institution will hold you until you can. In mid-2016 he relapsed in his heroin use and told members of his mental health team that he was severely depressed. The senators who later demanded an investigation stated the background plainly in their letter of August 2, 2016, to Inspector General Michael J. Missal: Ketchum had been in treatment with a psychiatrist at the facility for a year, the facility knew of his struggle with post-traumatic stress disorder, and his file carried, in their words, “repeated flags for suicide over the last three years.”
What happened
On July 7, 2016, Ketchum went to the Iowa City VA and requested inpatient treatment. The psychiatrist who saw him, Dr. Anthony Miller, declined to admit him. As the VA Office of Inspector General later recorded, Miller told him he believed his problems could be handled on an outpatient basis, and he noted that the hospital’s inpatient unit was full. The inspector general’s report adds the fact that frames everything after it: if the psychiatrist had believed Ketchum needed inpatient treatment, he could have sent him to a non-VA hospital. The bed count at Iowa City was not, on the record, the end of the options. The judgment was.
Ketchum became distraught and left the session abruptly. Miller’s own notes, as the inspector general reported them, record what happened next: the psychiatrist followed him into the parking lot and rapped on the hood of his Hyundai to get him to stop. Ketchum raised his arms in a shrug, as if to say, “What’s the point?” — and drove off. He drove home to Davenport. He texted his mother that the VA had “blood” on its hands.
Early the next morning, July 8, 2016, he wrote it down where anyone could read it, on Facebook: “Not only did I get a NO, but three reasons of no based (on) me not being ‘f—– up enough,’” he wrote. “They gave up on me, so why shouldn’t I give up on myself?” Later that day, his estranged girlfriend Kristine Nichols found his body at his home. He had died by a self-inflicted gunshot wound. He left a daughter, Layla.
The lawmakers who took up his case did not wait. On July 15, 2016 — one week after his death — Sen. Joni Ernst of Iowa wrote to both Inspector General Missal and VA Under Secretary for Health David Shulkin demanding an immediate and thorough investigation. On August 2, 2016, Ernst joined Sens. Chuck Grassley of Iowa and Ron Johnson of Wisconsin in urging the inspector general to examine Ketchum’s interactions with the Iowa City VA on July 7 “to determine what, if any, steps can be taken in the future to better protect our veteran population.” When months passed without a report, Ernst wrote again on November 10, 2016, counting the days in her letter: “Since my letter on July 15th, 118 days have gone by.”
What the institution did afterward
The VA’s Office of Inspector General investigated, and on August 3, 2017, it released its report, VAOIG-16-04535-329. The report did two things at once, and this page prints both, because the record is both.
First, it documented failures in the care around Brandon Ketchum. The inspector general found that the Iowa City facility had failed to adhere to Veterans Health Administration policies in three areas: follow-up after missed appointments — Ketchum had missed several appointments and had not always been contacted directly afterward; treatment planning, which was not kept up to date; and the assignment of a principal mental health provider, the clinician charged with coordinating a patient’s care. The inspectors also found that the VA team did not always communicate with each other about what Ketchum was saying — including his statement to a nurse that he was “not in a good place.” The report made four recommendations to improve mental health treatment going forward.
Second, the inspector general declined to hold the staff responsible for his death, and it said so in its own words. It concluded that staff were not directly responsible. Of the decision at the center of the case, it wrote: “The psychiatrist’s decision not to admit the patient was within acceptable practice based on the information available to him at the time.” And of the failures it had itself documented, it wrote: “It is difficult to determine the degree, if any, to which these shortcomings contributed to the patient’s death by suicide.” The report held the two conclusions side by side: had the admitting psychiatrist been aware of the extent of the patient’s psychosocial struggles, he may have decided to admit him — and the psychiatrist, it noted, made a good faith effort to re-engage the patient after he abruptly left the session. The shortcomings were real, on the inspector general’s own finding. Whether they mattered, on the inspector general’s own finding, could not be determined.
Iowa’s congressional delegation answered the report the day it appeared. Grassley, Ernst, and Rep. Dave Loebsack said in a joint statement: “This case is a tragic example of why we must do better for our veterans.” They noted the average the VA itself cited at the time — 20 veterans committing suicide a day — and closed with the only commitment the report left open: “We expect the VA to implement the recommendations thoroughly and carefully, and we intend to make sure the VA does so.”
No individual accountability followed in the record. What followed instead was legislation — first in earlier versions carried by Loebsack while he remained in Congress, and then, after his retirement in January 2021, in the bill that took Ketchum’s name into law.
Where it stands now
The Sgt. Ketchum Rural Veterans Mental Health Act of 2021 (H.R. 2441) was led in the House by Rep. Cindy Axne, with all four members of Iowa’s House delegation behind it — Axne, Rep. Ashley Hinson as the Republican lead, Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks, and Rep. Randy Feenstra — and Senate leadership from Veterans’ Affairs Chairman Jon Tester and Ranking Member Jerry Moran. Axne had worked with Ketchum’s mother on it, and she said on the floor what she had promised her: “When I introduced this legislation, I told Bev that Brandon’s story was one that would ensure that other veterans get the mental health help that they need.”
The House debated the bill on May 17, 2021 (Congressional Record, pages H2375–H2377) and passed it on May 18, 2021. The Senate approved it unanimously on June 24, 2021. On June 30, 2021, President Joe Biden signed it into law as Public Law 117-21. Three of Iowa’s House members stood in the Oval Office for the signing. When it was done, the President and Axne called Beverly “Bev” Kittoe from the Oval Office. “When he connected with Bev, Sergeant Ketchum’s mother, there was not a dry eye in the room,” Axne told Radio Iowa afterward.
What the law does is specific, aimed at the geography of the failure as Congress understood it — a veteran facing a full unit, in a region where the next door is far away:
- It directs the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to establish three new centers of the VA’s Rural Access Network for Growth Enhancement (RANGE) Program — small teams providing intensive outpatient mental health care and case management to rural veterans with serious mental illness — during fiscal year 2022.
- It authorizes $1.2 million for each of fiscal years 2022 through 2024 to carry that expansion out.
- It directs the Comptroller General — the Government Accountability Office — to study whether the VA has sufficient resources to serve rural veterans who need more intensive mental health care, including wait times and how many rural veterans died by suicide or overdose while on a wait list, with a report to the Veterans’ Affairs Committees due not later than 18 months after enactment.
Kittoe had said what she wanted from it when the bill was introduced, in the plainest terms on this page: “This is something that maybe will help someone. Even if it’s just one person.” And she said who her son had been, for the same record: “Brandon had the biggest heart. He always made sure others got what they needed before he got anything for himself.”
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- The VA Office of Inspector General investigated and reported (VAOIG-16-04535-329, released August 3, 2017): the Iowa City VA had failed to follow Veterans Health Administration policy on follow-up after missed appointments, on treatment planning, and on assignment of a principal mental health provider, and its team had not reliably shared what the patient was saying, including that he was “not in a good place.” The report made four recommendations.
- Congress acted in his name. The Sgt. Ketchum Rural Veterans Mental Health Act of 2021 passed the House on May 18, 2021, passed the Senate unanimously on June 24, 2021, and was signed by President Biden on June 30, 2021 as Public Law 117-21: three new RANGE Program centers to be established in fiscal year 2022, $1.2 million authorized for each of fiscal years 2022 through 2024, and a GAO study of rural veterans’ mental health care, reporting within 18 months of enactment.
- The President called the veteran’s mother from the Oval Office on the day the law was signed.
What has not been done
- The inspector general did not find the staff directly responsible for Ketchum’s death, and it held that the decision not to admit him was “within acceptable practice” — the documented failures around his care produced recommendations, not accountability for the outcome.
- The inspector general could not determine whether the shortcomings it documented contributed to his death: “It is difficult to determine the degree, if any, to which these shortcomings contributed to the patient’s death by suicide.” That question, in the official record, remains unanswered rather than answered.
- Brandon Ketchum asked for a bed on July 7, 2016, and the system that had flagged him for suicide risk over the preceding three years answered with outpatient care and a full unit. Nothing in the record since changes what happened to the request itself. The law his name carries builds rural outpatient teams and orders a study; it is prospective, and he is not here to be served by it.
What is being sought
- That the VA implement the inspector general’s four recommendations thoroughly and carefully — the commitment Iowa’s senators and representative stated on the record on August 3, 2017, adding that the VA should go beyond the recommendations if necessary, and that they intended to make sure it did so.
- That the RANGE expansion and the GAO study the 2021 Act ordered be carried out on the terms Congress wrote — three centers, in fiscal year 2022, and a public accounting of whether rural veterans can get intensive mental health care, what they wait for it, and what the waiting costs.
- What his mother asked for, in her own words, when the bill carrying his name was introduced: that it help someone. “Even if it’s just one person.”
Sources
- VA Office of Inspector General, report VAOIG-16-04535-329 (released August 3, 2017) — the investigation of Ketchum’s care at the Iowa City VA: the July 7, 2016 non-admission, the policy failures, the four recommendations, and the conclusions that staff were not directly responsible and the non-admission was “within acceptable practice,” as reported in the two accounts below: https://www.va.gov/oig/pubs/VAOIG-16-04535-329.pdf
- Associated Press (via North Dakota Insider), “VA not directly to blame for Iowa veteran Ketchum’s suicide, inspectors conclude,” August 3, 2017 — the inspector general’s findings and caveats, the parking-lot account, Ketchum’s Facebook post, and the Grassley–Ernst–Loebsack joint statement: https://www.ndinsider.com/story/news/health/2017/08/03/iowa-veterans-suicide-not-directly-blamed-on-va/538158001/
- Disabled Veterans, “No Vacancy: IG Says VA Rejected Suicidal Veteran Before Suicide,” August 4, 2017 — a close summary of the inspector general report, including its statement that “it is difficult to determine the degree, if any, to which these shortcomings contributed to the patient’s death by suicide”: https://www.disabledveterans.org/no-vacancy-ig-says-va-rejected-suicidal-veteran-suicide/
- U.S. Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, “Johnson, Grassley, Ernst Seek Inspector General Inquiry into Veteran’s Suicide,” August 2, 2016 — the senators’ letter to Inspector General Missal, recording Ketchum’s year of treatment and “repeated flags for suicide over the last three years”: https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/media/reps/johnson-grassley-ernst-seek-inspector-general-inquiry-into-veterans-suicide/
- Des Moines Register (via Rep. Ashley Hinson), “Late Marine ‘Had the Biggest Heart,’ Says Mom After Congress Introduces Veterans Bill Named After Him,” 2021 — the Register’s profile of Ketchum, his mid-2016 relapse, his daughter Layla, and Beverly Kittoe’s words on the bill: http://hinson.house.gov/media/in-the-news/late-marine-had-biggest-heart-says-mom-after-congress-introduces-veterans-bill
- Congressional Record — House, May 17, 2021, pages H2375–H2377 — the text of H.R. 2441 and the floor debate: Axne on the 92 roadside bombs and her promise to Bev Kittoe; Bost, Hinson, and Miller-Meeks on the July 2016 denial: https://www.congress.gov/117/crec/2021/05/17/167/85/CREC-2021-05-17-pt1-PgH2375.pdf
- WHO-TV and Radio Iowa (via Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks), “President Biden signs rural mental health act named for Iowa veteran into law,” June 30, 2021 — the Oval Office signing and the President’s call to Bev Kittoe: https://millermeeks.house.gov/media/in-the-news/president-biden-signs-rural-mental-health-act-named-iowa-veteran-law
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.