IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Ciara Durkin: Nine Months for an Answer, and the Warning She Left Behind

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Before Ciara Durkin went back to Afghanistan, she gave her family an instruction: she had found things in the finance office she did not like, she had made enemies because of it, and if anything happened to her, they were to make sure it was investigated. On September 28, 2007, something happened. What followed was nine months of shifting official language — killed in action, non-combat, undetermined — before the Army concluded she had died by her own hand. Her family, which included a sister who carried the fight to two United States senators and the Irish government, has never accepted that conclusion. This page prints the Army's finding and the family's belief side by side, and states as its own fact only the process, which is documented from the first confused press statement to the nine-month investigation. The record.

The service, and the promise

Ciara Marie Durkin was born July 6, 1977, in Ireland, and came to the United States as a child. She grew up in Quincy, Massachusetts, and served in the Massachusetts Army National Guard with the 726th Finance Battalion, based in West Newton. She deployed to Afghanistan in November 2006 and worked a desk job — payroll, the unglamorous machinery by which an army pays its people — about three miles inside the fortified perimeter of Bagram Air Base.

Finance work is fiduciary work. A finance soldier sees where the money goes, and in a war zone that means cash, contracts, and accounts in a place where all three were routinely abused. Durkin’s family has said, consistently and on the record since the week of her death, that she told them before returning from leave that she had discovered financial improprieties — “some things I don’t like,” in her sister Fiona Canavan’s recollection of her words — and that she had made enemies over it. She was also, as a matter of public record, openly gay at a time when the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy made that a career-ending fact, and she was counted after her death as the first openly LGBT soldier to die in the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. She was scheduled to come home in January 2008 and planned to marry her partner in Massachusetts.

The promise the Army made her is the standard one, and so is the promise it made her family: that if she died in its service, it would tell them, promptly and truthfully, how. The documented record of this case is largely the record of that second promise being kept slowly, in revisions.

What happened

On September 28, 2007, about ninety minutes after she left work, Durkin was found dead near a chapel inside the secure area of Bagram Air Base, with a single gunshot wound to the head. Hours before, she had left her brother an upbeat happy-birthday message by phone. She was thirty years old.

How the institution described it. The Army’s public account of her death changed as the days passed, and the changes are documented. The Massachusetts National Guard first said, on September 30, that Durkin had been killed “in action.” The Pentagon then described her death as the result of a “non-combat related incident,” with circumstances under investigation. The family was told she had been shot in the head inside a secure area — which led them, early on, to raise the possibility of so-called friendly fire. The cause of death was subsequently carried as undetermined while the investigation proceeded. Combat, then non-combat, then undetermined: three official characterizations before any finding existed.

The official finding. The Army’s investigation took nine months. In June 2008 it concluded that Durkin had died by suicide, by a single gunshot from her M-16. The investigators reported that she had attended a combat stress clinic on eleven occasions between April and June 2007, and that she had sent text messages disclosing an intention to kill herself. The investigation found no evidence that she was killed in a hate crime.

The family’s belief. The Durkins reject the suicide finding. Their case rests on things Ciara Durkin said and wrote while alive. Before she redeployed after leave, she told her family she had found financial irregularities, had made enemies, and instructed them — in the sentence her sister repeated to every reporter and official who would listen — “If anything happens to me, you guys make sure it gets investigated.” In June 2007, she wrote in an email that a fellow soldier had pulled a 9mm pistol on her. The family has also pointed to the circumstances: a single gunshot, inside a secure area, ninety minutes after work, on a day when she had sounded cheerful to her brother hours earlier. Her sister said the family discounted the possibility of suicide from the beginning and, after meeting with investigators, continued to do so even while acknowledging the investigation’s thoroughness in some respects.

This page adopts neither account. It records, as established, the two things neither side disputes: that the Army’s description of the death shifted repeatedly in the first weeks, and that the institution required nine months to produce the finding the family had been told might take eight weeks.

What the institution did afterward

The institution’s first failure in this case was not a conclusion. It was the sequence of statements — “in action,” then “non-combat,” then “undetermined” — each delivered with official weight and each withdrawn. A family can survive bad news. What the Durkins have described, from the first week, is the corrosive effect of news that keeps changing: every revision taught them to discount the next statement, including the final one.

The investigation itself ran nine months, against an early estimate given to the family of as long as eight weeks. During those nine months the family did what the families on this wall always end up doing: they escalated. They pressed Senator John Kerry and Senator Edward Kennedy of Massachusetts and Representative William Delahunt, who took the case up directly — Kerry wrote to Secretary of Defense Robert Gates urging him “to deploy your staff on this matter immediately, so that the answers and circumstances around Specialist Durkin’s death are uncovered, expeditiously and thoroughly.” Because Durkin was born in Ireland and her family spanned both countries, they also enlisted the Irish government; her ashes were brought home to Galway and buried beside her father at Lettermore in October 2007, while the investigation that would explain her death still had eight months to run. The Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, which advocated for gay service members then serving under “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” joined the call for a full and thorough investigation.

When the finding came, in June 2008, it was suicide, supported by the combat-stress visits and the text messages the investigators cited. The family’s answer was the one Ciara Durkin had pre-written for them: they had been told by the soldier herself to make sure it got investigated, and in their judgment the investigation had not answered the things she warned them about — the financial improprieties she said she found, the enemies she said she made, the pistol she said was pulled on her. No public accounting has ever addressed those three specifics on their own terms.

Where it stands now

The Army’s finding stands: suicide, case concluded in June 2008, no evidence of a hate crime found. No other official body has reopened the matter, and no charges of any kind arose from her death or from the financial improprieties she reported to her family.

The family’s position also stands, unchanged since 2007. The Durkins carried out the instruction she left them for nine months of investigation and years of public advocacy, and they have never withdrawn their objection. Her case remains a standard reference in the literature of disputed military deaths — notable in the surveys for the specificity of the warning she left, for the congressional and international pressure her family brought to bear, and for the fact that neither moved the institution’s timeline or its conclusion.

What remains on the documented record, and what this page states as its own conclusion, is narrower and harder than either side’s account of the shot: the Army described this death three different ways before it investigated it; it estimated eight weeks and took nine months; it was pressed by two senators, a congressman, and a foreign government, and the timetable did not change; and the soldier’s own stated concerns — money she said was wrong, a weapon she said was drawn on her — were never publicly answered. Whatever happened near the chapel at Bagram, the process by which the institution explained it to her family is fully documented, and it is the process that put her name on this wall.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door