IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Deborah Sampson: The Soldier Who Fought for Her Country, Then Spent a Lifetime Fighting It for Her Pay

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Deborah Sampson did the one thing the young republic said a woman could not do: she put on a uniform, marched with a light infantry company, took wounds in combat, and came home with an honorable discharge. Then she spent the rest of her life — and her husband spent the rest of his, and the claim outlived them both — asking the government to pay for service it did not dispute she had performed. This page is the documented record of that second, longer war: forty-six years of petitions for a soldier's pay, told in dates and dollar figures.

The service, and the promise

Deborah Sampson was born on December 17, 1760, in Plympton, Massachusetts, into a family that fell apart under poverty; as a girl she was bound out as an indentured servant. In May 1782 she bound her chest, took the name Robert Shurtleff, and enlisted in the Continental Army. She was mustered into the 4th Massachusetts Regiment, in a light infantry company — the kind of unit that marched at the front and was expected to fight.

She served approximately seventeen months. The record of that service, as her 1797 biographer Herman Mann set it down and as the Army’s own rolls confirm, is a soldier’s record: Robert Shurtleff served from May 20, 1782, to October 25, 1783. She was wounded in fighting near Tarrytown, New York — a saber cut to the head and a musket ball in the thigh. By the standard accounts she treated the leg wound herself rather than submit to a surgeon’s examination and be discovered. In 1783, ill with fever in Philadelphia, she came under the care of a doctor who learned her secret — and kept it, sending her on with a letter rather than an exposure. On October 25, 1783, at West Point, she was honorably discharged. Her officers, who by then knew who she was, let the discharge stand on the merits of the service.

The promise embedded in that discharge is the same one made to every soldier of the Revolution: serve, and the country will pay you — your wages while you serve, and a provision afterward if the service disables you. Sampson’s case is the measure of what that promise was worth to a soldier whose service was undeniable and whose sex was not.

What happened

Sampson came home to Massachusetts and, on April 7, 1785, married Benjamin Gannett, a farmer of Sharon. They raised three children and adopted a fourth. The marriage was, by every account, a working farm family’s life — which is to say, a life lived close to the edge of money. The back pay owed to Robert Shurtleff for seventeen months in the ranks had never been paid.

In January 1792, Sampson petitioned the Massachusetts legislature for the back pay the Army had withheld. The legislature did not dispute the service. On January 20, 1792, it awarded her a one-time payment of £34 — the wages of the soldier she had been, paid nearly nine years after the discharge. It was the first installment on the debt, and it was all the Commonwealth proposed to pay.

The federal obligation was separate, and it was there that the fight stalled. Sampson’s wounds qualified her, on paper, for an invalid pension — the provision the federal government made for soldiers disabled in service. She petitioned. The petitions went nowhere for more than a decade. What moved the case was not a form or a finding but a personal intervention: in January 1804, Paul Revere — silversmith, patriot, and the most famous messenger in America — visited the Gannett farm, satisfied himself of the facts, and wrote to Congressman William Eustis on her behalf, pressing her claim as one of simple justice owed to a soldier.

Only then did the machinery turn. In 1805 Sampson was placed on the federal pension roll as an invalid pensioner at $4 a month — $48 a year, with a lump sum of $104 in arrears. Twenty-two years after her discharge, the United States began paying the wounded soldier of the 4th Massachusetts four dollars a month. She is identified by the National Women’s History Museum as the only woman to earn a military pension for participation in the Revolutionary army. It is worth pausing on the arithmetic: the pension was real, and it was also, for a farm family carrying a disabled veteran, very close to nothing.

Sampson did not retire into the pension. She had already, in 1802, taken to the lecture stage — the first American woman to make a national lecture tour — telling the story of Robert Shurtleff in public, appearing in her uniform, in part because the family needed the money. Even the pension she had won proved unstable: in 1818 she gave up the disability pay for a general service pension of $96 a year, and the fight for retroactive payments — for the full amount the service had owed since 1783 — continued, in petition after petition, for the rest of her life. She was still pursuing it when she died of yellow fever on April 29, 1827, in Sharon, aged sixty-six — forty-four years after her discharge, with the account of Robert Shurtleff still not settled.

What the institution did afterward

The war for Sampson’s pay did not end with her death; it changed claimants. Four years after her death, Benjamin Gannett petitioned Congress for a pension as the widower of a Revolutionary veteran. The petition was, on its face, unprecedented: the government was being asked to recognize, for purposes of a survivor’s benefit, that a woman had been a soldier and that her husband was a soldier’s widower.

Congress’s committee took the measure of the case in 1837 and concluded, in words that have been quoted ever since, that the history of the Revolution “furnished no other similar example of female heroism, fidelity and courage.” The praise was unanimous. The money was not forthcoming in time to matter to the man who had earned the right to ask for it. Benjamin Gannett died in January 1837 — before receiving anything.

On July 7, 1838, Congress finally acted, passing the act that paid Deborah Sampson’s claim in full — to her heirs, her children. The Pension Commissioner’s own letter, preserved with the record of the case, confirms the payment: $466.66 to the heirs of Deborah Sampson Gannett. The correspondence on the claim ran to 1838; Herman Mann’s biography — The Female Review, first published in 1797 and reprinted with the pension documents — carries the file of a claim that had begun with a petition for back pay in 1792 and closed forty-six years later, paid to the children of a soldier eleven years dead and a widower eighteen months in his grave.

Where it stands now

Deborah Sampson’s service is not in dispute anywhere. Massachusetts proclaimed her its official state heroine in 1982 and set May 23 as Deborah Sampson Day. A statue stands outside the public library in Sharon; a Liberty ship of the Second World War carried her married name. The record that survives — her discharge, her 1792 petition, Revere’s 1804 letter, the pension records of 1805, the committee report of 1837, the act of July 7, 1838, and the Pension Commissioner’s letter confirming the $466.66 paid to her heirs — is unusually complete for an enlisted soldier of the Revolution, let alone an enlisted woman.

What that complete record documents is not a denial. It is something this site encounters again and again: a debt acknowledged at every step and paid at a pace that made the payment nearly useless to the people owed. Massachusetts took nine years to pay a private’s back wages. The federal government took twenty-two years to begin paying a wounded soldier $4 a month, and moved then only because Paul Revere personally wrote the letter. The final settlement took fifty-five years from the discharge and was delivered to orphans. No one in the long file ever wrote that Deborah Sampson had not earned the money. They simply took two generations to pay it.

The ledger

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought


Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door