Doris Miller: The Hero of Pearl Harbor Whom the Navy Would Not Give Its Highest Honor
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Doris "Dorie" Miller did the thing the Medal of Honor exists to recognize, in front of an entire fleet, on the most documented morning in American naval history. He was a mess attendant — the only work the segregated Navy of 1941 allowed a Black sailor to do was serving white officers — and when the attack came he fought a weapon he had never been trained to touch, then went back into the fire to carry wounded men, including his dying captain. The Navy's first public word about him did not include his name. Its Secretary then wrote against the medal Congress tried to give him. Miller was dead within two years, killed in the war the Navy would not fully honor him for fighting. His family has been asking for the rest of it ever since. This page is the documented record.
The service, and the promise
Doris Miller was born on October 12, 1919, in Waco, Texas, the third of four sons of Connery and Henrietta Miller, sharecroppers. He enlisted in the U.S. Navy at Dallas on September 16, 1939, and was assigned to the battleship USS West Virginia at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii.
The Navy he joined sorted men by race before it sorted them by ability. Black sailors were confined almost entirely to the messman branch: they cooked, they served officers, they cleaned. They were not trained on the ship’s weapons, because the Navy did not intend them to fight. Miller’s rating — mess attendant — meant that when his ship went to war, the service’s own plan for him was to be below deck with the laundry. On the morning of December 7, 1941, Miller was collecting laundry when the Japanese attack began.
The promise the Navy makes to every sailor is that gallantry will be recognized as gallantry, without regard to the man. The record of what the Navy did with Doris Miller’s gallantry is the subject of this page, and it begins with the fact that for months, the Navy’s recognition of its first hero of the war did not include his name.
What happened
When general quarters sounded, Miller went to his battle station and found it already destroyed by a torpedo. He went up to the deck of a battleship under air attack and did, in sequence, the things his Navy Cross citation would later describe: he carried wounded sailors to shelter, including the West Virginia’s commanding officer, Captain Mervyn S. Bennion, who had been mortally wounded on his own bridge and whom Miller and others moved to a safer position before Bennion died. Then Miller took position at an anti-aircraft machine gun — a weapon he had never been trained on, in a Navy that had deliberately never trained him — and fired on the attacking aircraft until his ammunition was gone. Then he went back to moving wounded men through burning oil and wreckage.
Sixteen men received the Medal of Honor for their actions at Pearl Harbor. The congressional bills later filed in Miller’s name state the comparison plainly: of the sailors awarded the Medal of Honor for similar actions during the attack, not one was African American. Miller was not among them. He was not, at first, even named.
On December 15, 1941, the Navy released its commendations for Pearl Harbor. The list included, in the words Congress itself later put in a bill’s findings, one “unnamed Negro.” The Navy’s commendation of the sailor who had manned the gun and carried his captain identified him only by his race. It took the Black press — the Pittsburgh Courier, in March 1942 — to establish for the public record that the unnamed man was Doris Miller of Waco, Texas.
Miller himself did not stop being a sailor while Washington decided what he was. He was sent on a war-bond and recruiting tour, promoted in June 1943 to Cook Third Class, and returned to sea aboard the escort carrier USS Liscome Bay. On November 24, 1943, off Makin Atoll in the Gilbert Islands, the Japanese submarine I-175 put a torpedo into Liscome Bay’s bomb magazine. The carrier sank in minutes with the loss of 702 officers and sailors — the deadliest carrier sinking in U.S. Navy history. Doris Miller, twenty-four years old, was among them. His parents in Waco buried a son the Navy had first honored without naming.
What the institution did afterward
Congress moved first, and the Navy’s civilian chief moved against it.
In March 1942, Representative John Dingell Sr. of Michigan introduced a bill in the House to award Miller the Medal of Honor, and Senator James M. Mead of New York introduced the measure in the Senate. The Black press and the NAACP campaigned for the award. The response from the Secretary of the Navy, Frank Knox — a man on record opposing Black sailors in combat roles altogether — was a letter to the Senate committee recommending against the Medal of Honor. Knox’s position, as the Congressional Research Service’s history of the case records it, was that Miller’s actions did not warrant the medal. In May 1942, the Senate voted the award down.
What Miller received instead, with President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s approval on May 11, 1942, was the Navy Cross — the Navy’s highest decoration below the Medal of Honor. Admiral Chester W. Nimitz pinned it on Miller aboard the carrier Enterprise at Pearl Harbor on May 27, 1942. Miller was the first Black sailor in American history to receive it.
The Navy put its hero to work in the interval. Miller was toured through the country in 1942 and 1943 as the face of its bond and recruiting campaigns — photographed at the Naval Training Station at Great Lakes in January 1943 wearing the Navy Cross, proof in a recruiting poster that Black Americans should enlist in the very service that had voted down his medal and confined his rating to the officers’ mess. He performed the duty as he had performed the other. Then he was sent back to sea, to the Liscome Bay and to November 24, 1943.
The context the institution created around that award is a matter of arithmetic. No Black sailor, soldier, or Marine received the Medal of Honor in all of World War II — not Miller at Pearl Harbor, not any of the more than a million Black Americans who served. When the Army finally re-examined its own World War II awards in the 1990s, seven Black soldiers received the medal in 1997, half a century late, and only one of them was alive to wear it. No equivalent correction has ever been completed for the Navy, and none at all for Doris Miller. The Army’s seven were corrected because the Army was made to study its files. Doris Miller’s file sits in the other service, where the sentence that decided it was written by the Secretary himself: the actions did not warrant the medal. No board has ever struck that sentence.
Where it stands now
The fight did not end with Miller’s family; it has been carried by them, and by members of Congress, for more than eighty years.
In January 2020, at a Martin Luther King Jr. Day ceremony at Pearl Harbor, Acting Secretary of the Navy Thomas B. Modly announced that the future aircraft carrier CVN-81 would be named USS Doris Miller — the first aircraft carrier ever named for a Black American, and the first named for an enlisted sailor. Miller’s family stood at the ceremony and unveiled the plaque. It was a substantial honor, and it is also, on the record, a substitution: the Navy has now named its largest class of warship for a man it still has not given the medal its own Secretary argued against in 1942.
The medal fight continues in the open. Bills to authorize the President to award Miller the Medal of Honor posthumously — waiving the statutory time limits, as Congress had to do for the Army’s seven in 1997 — have been introduced in Congress after Congress, most recently H.R. 2335 in the 119th Congress, introduced March 25, 2025. None has been enacted. Miller’s family, speaking through his great-nephew Thomas Bledsoe, still seeks the Medal of Honor — not a ship’s name instead of it, but the medal itself, for the morning of December 7, 1941.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- The Navy Cross, presented by Admiral Chester W. Nimitz aboard USS Enterprise at Pearl Harbor on May 27, 1942 — making Miller the first Black sailor to receive the decoration.
- A frigate, USS Miller (FF-1091), commissioned in his name in 1973.
- The naming of the aircraft carrier CVN-81 as USS Doris Miller, announced January 20, 2020, at Pearl Harbor — the first carrier named for a Black American or for an enlisted sailor — with Miller’s family present at the ceremony.
What has not been done
- The Medal of Honor. Congress moved to award it in March 1942; Secretary of the Navy Frank Knox recommended against it in writing; the Senate voted it down in May 1942. The Navy’s first commendation of Miller did not even carry his name — he was entered as an unnamed “Negro,” and it fell to the Pittsburgh Courier to name him in March 1942.
- No Black service member received the Medal of Honor for World War II service during the war or for decades after it. The Army corrected its record for seven men in 1997. The Navy has never completed the same correction for Doris Miller.
What is being sought
- The Medal of Honor itself, posthumously, under congressional authorization waiving the time limits — the remedy bills for Miller have been introduced repeatedly, most recently as H.R. 2335 (119th Congress, March 25, 2025). His family, through great-nephew Thomas Bledsoe, continues to seek it more than eighty years after the morning that earned it.
Sources
- Congressional Research Service, “Medal of Honor: History and Issues” (RS22478), via EveryCRSReport — the Miller nomination, Secretary Knox’s recommendation against the award, and the Senate’s 1942 disposition: https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/RS22478.html
- World War II On Deadline, “Doris Miller” (October 12, 2020) — the 1942 congressional effort and the Navy’s “unnamed” commendation: https://ww2ondeadline.com
- Baylor Line, “Erasing Doris Miller” — the Waco family’s record and the carrier naming: https://baylorline.com
- U.S. Navy, CHIPS, “Navy Names Future Aircraft Carrier Doris Miller During MLK, Jr. Day Ceremony” (January 20, 2020) — the CVN-81 naming, the family’s presence, and the first-carrier facts: https://www.doncio.navy.mil/CHIPS/ArticleDetails.aspx?ID=13119
- H.R. 2335, 119th Congress (introduced March 25, 2025) — the pending authorization, including Congress’s own findings that the Navy’s December 15, 1941 commendations listed one “unnamed Negro” and that of the sailors awarded the Medal of Honor for similar actions at Pearl Harbor, not one was African American.
- Naval History and Heritage Command / DANFS, USS Liscome Bay (CVE-56) — the torpedoing of November 24, 1943, and the 702 lost.
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.