IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Dwight W. Birdwell: The Soldier Who Held Tan Son Nhut and Waited 54 Years for the Medal

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Dwight W. Birdwell's commanding officer told him, days after the fight, that he was initiating the process for the Medal of Honor. Then that officer was gravely wounded and evacuated before the paperwork was completed, and the process stopped with him. Birdwell came home with a Silver Star, built a life and a law practice in Oklahoma, and waited — through a promise made by a four-star general in 1981, that general's death in 2013, and the work of the successor he had designated to carry the file. This page is the documented record: what Birdwell did on January 31, 1968, and the day, 54 years later, when the medal his commander had promised was finally placed in his hands.

The service, and the promise

Dwight W. Birdwell served in Vietnam with C Troop, 3rd Squadron, 4th Cavalry, 25th Infantry Division. He is a citizen of the Cherokee Nation. Birdwell credits the Cherokee veterans who came before him, who encouraged him to serve when he was called — a credit President Joe Biden recorded at the 2022 ceremony, noting that Native American communities serve in the U.S. Armed Forces at a higher percentage rate than any other cohort in America.

The promise in Birdwell’s case was not abstract. It was spoken to him directly, by the officer who had watched the fight. Several days after January 31, 1968, his commanding officer, Lt. Col. Glenn Otis, let him know — in Birdwell’s own words in AARP The Magazine — that “he was going to initiate a process for me to be considered for the Medal of Honor, the nation’s highest honor for valor in battle.”

A process initiated by a commanding officer is the institution’s promise in its most concrete form: the commander has judged the action, named the award, and started the paperwork. The paperwork was never completed. No one with the authority to finish it picked it up when Otis fell. Birdwell’s own account begins not with bureaucracy but with a question he says he was left to ask himself — recorded here as his question, in his words, and as nothing more proven than that. His hesitation opens the account: “I am hesitant to talk about what happened that day — January 31, 1968. A lot of brave men lost their lives or were gravely wounded.”

What happened

January 31, 1968 was the opening assault of the Tet Offensive. Enemy forces launched an attack on Tan Son Nhut Air Base, near Saigon. The first American unit called to respond was Birdwell’s.

His Medal of Honor citation, read aloud at the White House on July 5, 2022, records the action in the Army’s own words. C Troop was ordered to move south to help repel the attack. As the column of tanks and armored personnel carriers approached the West Gate of the airbase, it came under intense fire from a building at its right. Unbeknown to C Troop, it had driven directly into an enemy force of three battalions. The lead tank, crippled by rocket-propelled grenade explosions, was blocking the way forward, and C Troop came under heavy fire from both sides of the road.

Birdwell’s own account gives the same fight in plainer language: “we were two platoons, no more than 80 U.S. Army troops total, facing at least 1,000 Vietcong soldiers who were trying to capture the base. In the fighting, one of our platoons was completely wiped out. Those of us who were left in the other platoon received fire from both sides.” Biden’s account put C Troop at approximately 100 men against a full regiment likely more than 1,000 strong.

What Birdwell did, step by step, is in the citation:

Biden’s account adds the evacuation Birdwell finally accepted, and how: when he was ordered to load onto the medevac helicopter, he complied — “only to crawl right back off the other side — and to keep on fighting.” Only after reinforcements arrived, and only after he helped treat the evacuees — his fellow wounded — did Birdwell agree to evacuate himself.

The citation’s judgment is the Army’s: his “leadership and tenacity under fire inspired the other C Troop soldiers to continue fighting against the superior enemy force and directly contributed to the enemy’s ultimate defeat.” Birdwell’s judgment points away from himself: “the medal is really for the guys who were killed that day, the guys who were seriously wounded, and their families. I will never forget them or what they sacrificed. I’m the one who received the medal, but it belongs to them too.”

What the institution did afterward

Birdwell was awarded the Silver Star. “I was awarded the Silver Star, which is nothing to sneeze at,” he wrote. “But it’s not the same thing.”

The Medal of Honor process Otis had promised was never completed, for the reason Birdwell’s account states plainly: “But before he could complete the process, he was gravely wounded and evacuated.” After that, in Birdwell’s one-word summary of what happened with the medal over the years that followed — the word he would use to Otis himself in 1981 — the answer was: “Nothing.”

Birdwell has also recorded the treatment that framed his question about that nothing. “I am a citizen of the Cherokee Nation,” he wrote. “I got a lot of flak for that in Vietnam. People said, ‘Don’t give him firewater or he’ll go crazy’ or ‘He’ll scalp us while we’re sleeping.’ Along with Mexican soldiers and Black soldiers, I faced this kind of prejudice again and again. And I had to wonder whether the color of my skin had anything to do with my not getting put in for the Medal of Honor.”

That sentence is presented here exactly as Birdwell wrote it — as his wondering, and never stated by him, or by any finding cited here, as the proven reason the paperwork stopped. What is proven is narrower: his commander was evacuated before he could finish the process, and for decades no completed process replaced the interrupted one.

He came home in December 1968. Months afterward, he married Virginia. They had two children. When he got back to the States, he wrote, he was surprised by the attitude of a lot of people he encountered: compared to the reception given veterans of Korea, the Second World War, and the First, “it was a cold reception.”

The correction, when it finally moved, moved because Otis moved it. In 1981, Birdwell met up with Glenn Otis, who was by then a four-star general. Otis asked what had happened with the Medal of Honor. When Birdwell told him, “Nothing,” Otis said: “Someday, we’re going to have that corrected.” Later on, Otis initiated the process — again — and took one further step that decided whether the file would outlive him: he designated a retired major named Jerry Headley to see it through in the event of his death.

Otis died in 2013. The designation held. Headley and a Vietnam veteran named Bob Pedigo kept working on the medal process — “which is really rigorous,” Birdwell wrote — for the nine years that remained. Biden’s remarks credit the same man: in retirement, General Otis “made sure to correct the record and fully document Birdwell’s actions to make this day possible.” Biden also placed the day in a wider accounting: the July 5, 2022 presentations followed a congressionally ordered review of the heroic actions of Asian American, Native American, and Pacific Islander service members awarded high decorations during the Korean and Vietnam wars.

Where it stands now

On July 5, 2022 — 54 years after Tan Son Nhut — President Biden presented Birdwell with the Medal of Honor in the East Room of the White House, at the same ceremony that upgraded three other Vietnam soldiers: Staff Sergeant Edward N. Kaneshiro, honored posthumously, Specialist Five Dennis M. Fujii, and Major John J. Duffy. “We’re upgrading the awards of four soldiers who performed acts of incredible heroism during the Vietnam conflict,” Biden said. “Today, we’re setting the record straight.”

Two absences and one presence at that ceremony are part of the record. Birdwell’s wife Virginia, who had been with him since the months after he came home in December 1968, could not attend. Biden addressed her from the podium: “And to your wife, Virginia, who I know wishes she could be here with you today, give her our love as well.” Beside Birdwell stood his daughter Stephanie Birdwell: Birdwell had started his own law firm and served 12 years on the Cherokee Nation Supreme Court, and his daughter was present in her own office, as Director of the Office of Tribal Relations at the Department of Veterans Affairs.

Biden closed Birdwell’s portion with the sentence the 54 years had been waiting for: “I’m grateful for all you’ve given to our country and that at long last — at long last, your story is being honored as it should have been always.”

Birdwell’s own accounting: “I was very, very honored that day, and I still am,” he wrote. “Having the medal has changed my outlook somewhat. It has helped to offset some of the bitterness of the past.” He is, in AARP The Magazine’s closing note, a former Army Specialist 5, aged 77, a retired attorney in Oklahoma.

The record is now correct at the top: the citation carries the date, the unit, and the standard his commander named for him in 1968. What the correction cannot return is the interval: a promise spoken by a wounded commander, a file no one completed, thirteen years before that commander could take it up again, and a medal presented to a retired attorney rather than to the young soldier who had stood exposed in a tank hatch at Tan Son Nhut. The file was finished by the men who had started it — Otis, and after his death the successor he had named — not by the institution acting on its own motion.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door