IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Edward Day Cohota: Thirty Years in the Uniform of a Country That Would Not Call Him a Citizen

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Edward Day Cohota gave the United States Army the whole of his working life: enlisted as a boy in the Civil War, in the ranks at Cold Harbor — where he saved a fellow soldier's life — at Petersburg, and at Appomattox; reenlisted when the war ended and served some thirty more years in the Regular Army on the frontier; wounded in the service; retired in 1895. In 1912 he applied for a homestead, and the government of the United States informed him, for the first time, that he was not and had never been an American citizen — and that the law forbade him ever to become one. He died in 1935, still an alien, in the country whose uniform he had worn for three decades. This page is the documented record.

The service, and the promise

Cohota was born near Shanghai, China, in the early 1840s, and was brought to America as a small child — discovered, by the standard account, as a half-starved stowaway boy, his older brother dead beside him, aboard the merchant ship Cohota, two days out of Shanghai. Her captain, Sargent S. Day of Gloucester, Massachusetts, took the surviving boy in, named him Edward Day Cohota — his own Christian name and surname, and the ship’s name for a family name — and raised him in the Day household in Gloucester. The boy sailed with the Days, grew up an American in every particular of language, schooling, church, and loyalty, and believed — as the system that raised him had every reason to let him believe — that he was one.

When the Civil War came, he enlisted — underage, with Captain Day signing the papers on his behalf — in Company I, 23rd Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry, mustered in February 1864. He fought with the Army of the Potomac through the Overland Campaign: at Cold Harbor, where he saved the life of a fellow soldier under fire; through the siege of Petersburg; and to the end at Appomattox. He was wounded in the service.

When the volunteers went home, Cohota stayed. He reenlisted in the Regular Army — his approved pension file traces his Regular service through Companies C and H of the 15th U.S. Infantry and Companies B and G of the 8th U.S. Infantry — and spent the next three decades in uniform on the frontier posts of the West, rising through the long, unglamorous service of the peacetime army: Fort Randall in Dakota Territory, Fort Niobrara in Nebraska, and the other stations of a soldier’s whole career. He had fought his first battle — Drewry’s Bluff, near Richmond, on May 16, 1864 — within weeks of his muster, and the Army he then joined for life was the only institution he ever belonged to: it fed him, posted him, paid him, promoted him, and in time pensioned him, across thirty years and the whole width of the continent it was garrisoning. He married and raised his family in Nebraska — six children, American-born — while he soldiered at the posts nearby. He retired in 1895, with roughly thirty years of service in total, and settled among the people his service had been spent defending, entirely certain of the fact that seemed most obvious about him: that a man does not spend thirty years in a nation’s army, bleed for it, marry and raise citizens in it, without being of it.

What happened

The discovery came in 1912, in the most ordinary transaction an old soldier could attempt. Cohota applied for a homestead claim in Nebraska — public land, offered under the homestead laws to settlers who would work it. The claim was denied. The ground was not his service record, his character, or his residence of more than half a century. The ground was that he was not a citizen of the United States — and homesteads were for citizens.

He had believed his enlistment and service had made him one; the law of the Civil War era did offer citizenship to foreign-born soldiers, and Cohota had even voted, since the 1860s, in the honest belief that he was entitled. What he had never done was complete the formal naturalization paperwork — and by 1912 the door that paperwork would have opened was not merely closed but barred by statute. The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 prohibited the naturalization of Chinese immigrants altogether: not delayed, not conditioned — prohibited, by race and birthplace, categorically. The soldier of Cold Harbor applied to become a citizen of the country he had fought for, and the law answered that a man born in China could not.

Even the one thing the government did owe him on paper did not come clean. When Cohota requested his veteran’s pension, that too was challenged before it was granted — the old soldier’s file disputed, the compensation he had earned questioned — though in the end the pension was approved. The pension file is instructive precisely because it succeeded: the system could be made, with effort, to pay the man. It could not be made to own him as a citizen.

He took the citizenship case where such cases went: to Congress. Senator Norris Brown of Nebraska backed him, and his case was presented for legislative relief — a private act to make one old soldier a citizen, notwithstanding the Exclusion Act. Congress declined to act. There the matter rested, permanently. The Chinese Exclusion Act was not repealed until 1943, in the middle of another war, eight years after Cohota’s death.

What the institution did afterward

Cohota was widowed in 1898, and spent his last years among his adult children — the American citizens he had raised in Nebraska and South Dakota, children of a father their country refused to naturalize — and died in 1935, in his nineties, still not a citizen of the United States. The Cape Ann Museum, in his hometown of Gloucester, records the end plainly: in 1912 his homestead request “was denied on the grounds that he was not an American citizen. When he sought permission to become a citizen, his request was denied.”

The institutional afterlife of the case is a study in what recognition without remedy looks like. In 2015 the National Park Service recognized Cohota among the Asian and Pacific Islander soldiers of the Civil War. In 2023 the Department of Veterans Affairs — the institution that administers the benefits of the nation’s veterans — named him its Army Veteran of the Day (VA News, May 15, 2023), honoring “Army Veteran Edward Cohota,” a “Chinese immigrant and Civil War Veteran who served for over thirty years.” The VA’s own account states the conclusion without emphasis, because the facts carry it: “despite his service in the Army, Cohota never became a citizen.”

Efforts were made, within living memory, to obtain his citizenship posthumously. They did not succeed. The bar that kept him out was not an oversight in his file; it was a statute aimed at his birth, and statutes of that kind do not make individual exceptions out of embarrassment.

Where it stands now

Edward Day Cohota’s grave is in Mount Hope Cemetery, Valentine, Nebraska, in the country he tried to homestead. The documented record of the case contains no error to correct in his service — the service is confirmed by his compiled records, his approved pension file, and the Army’s own profiles. The failure was not administrative confusion about what he had done; it was a legal order under which what he had done did not count toward the one status that mattered, because of where he had been born in the early 1840s and what he looked like when he was carried ashore as a starving child.

His children were citizens — birthright citizens, born in Nebraska — of a republic that held their father to be an alien for the whole of his ninety-odd years, including the thirty he spent in its uniform and the fifty he spent living under its flag in its own West. That sentence is not rhetoric; it is the legal fact pattern of the file, and this page knows no better way to state the case than to state it.

He had written his own claim, in his petition for citizenship, and the words survive in the record: “I believe that I, if anyone, have earned the right to be pronounced a citizen of the United States and enjoy all of its rights and privileges… I respectfully ask that some action be taken that will enable me to become a citizen of the United States of America.” No action was taken.

The ledger

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought


Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door