The Freshwater Family: Two Sons, a Mother's Leukemias, and the Daughter Left With Two Cardboard Boxes
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Mary Freshwater never wore a uniform. She was a Marine's wife, and in the 1970s she lived where the Marine Corps housed its families — in Tarawa Terrace, at Camp Lejeune, North Carolina — drinking, cooking with, and bathing in the water the base supplied. She had borne two healthy children before the family's Lejeune years. At Lejeune, the record her daughter later filed in federal court alleges, the pattern broke: a son born with an open spine who lived one month, a son born without a cranium who lived one day, a miscarriage of twins, and, decades later, two acute leukemias that killed Mary herself on January 17, 2013. No one warned the family. No remedy existed for family members in her lifetime; a damages route arrived only in 2022, nine years after her death. What her daughter Lori inherited, in Lori's own words, was two cardboard boxes: one holding all that was left of her baby brother's short life, and one holding her mother's ashes. On August 31, 2022, Lori Freshwater filed the lawsuit her mother never lived to file.
The service, and the promise
The Freshwaters were a Marine Corps family, and in the 1970s the Corps housed them in Tarawa Terrace, the base’s family-housing area, served by its own water treatment plant. Lori Freshwater’s 2022 complaint states the framework in the statute’s terms: Mary Freshwater resided at Camp Lejeune and was exposed for not less than thirty days between August 1, 1953 and December 31, 1987, to water supplied by the United States — and Lori was exposed the same way.
The promise made to such a family is the quietest the military makes. A service family does not choose its housing or its water. It drinks what comes out of the taps the service provides, on the understanding that the institution is watching them on the family’s behalf.
What was in the Tarawa Terrace water is recited in the complaint from the government’s own health agency’s work. The source was the waste-disposal practices of ABC One-Hour Cleaners, an off-base dry-cleaning firm, whose solvent — tetrachloroethylene, PCE — reached the housing area’s wells. The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) estimated that PCE exceeded the current federal maximum contaminant level of 5 parts per billion in Tarawa Terrace drinking water for 346 months, from November 1957 to February 1987. The base’s own sampling found PCE as high as 104 parts per billion in July 1982 and 215 parts per billion in February 1985; the median estimated concentration from 1975 to January 1985 was 85 parts per billion, in the years this family was drinking it. The Freshwater sons were born in 1977 and 1979.
What happened
After two healthy children born before Lejeune, Mary’s pregnancies at Lejeune ended, one after another, in loss. The particulars here are taken from the complaint Lori Freshwater filed as executor of her mother’s estate and from the family’s August 2022 claim announcement — and they are carried as what they legally are: allegations, never, as of these sources, adjudicated. Birth-defect causation in this family is alleged, not adjudicated.
On November 30, 1977, Mary gave birth to a son, Alexander Russell Thorpe — “Rusty.” The complaint records his condition as a loss of child due to spina bifida: he was born with an open spine, a neural tube defect, the class of defect in which the spinal column fails to close in the first weeks of gestation. He died on January 1, 1978, at one month old.
On February 17, 1979, Mary gave birth to a second son, Charles Warner Thorpe. The complaint’s words are stark and this page keeps them: he was “born without cranium.” He was born and died the same day; the complaint enters him in a single parenthesis: “Charles Warner Thorpe (born and died 2/17/79).” The complaint also lists, among Mary’s own harms, a miscarriage of twins. (The family’s August 10, 2022 claim announcement frames the pregnancy losses as “two miscarriages borne by Mary Freshwater”; the complaint’s list says a miscarriage of twins. The variance is noted here and in the sources; the losses are constant across both accounts.)
Mary kept what was left of her first lost son in a small cardboard box — the box she held in the documentary Semper Fi: Always Faithful, saying, in the words her daughter carried into the 2022 announcement: “We are not numbers in a study. We are human beings that have had great tragedies.”
The last entries in the complaint’s list of Mary’s diagnoses are her own: acute myeloid leukemia and adult acute lymphoblastic leukemia — two types of acute leukemia, in the claim announcement’s phrasing, from whose complications she died. Mary Freshwater was born on May 27, 1944. She died on January 17, 2013, at sixty-eight — thirty-five years after Rusty, thirty-four after Charles. The complaint states the family’s position in the Act’s terms: “As a direct and proximate cause of her exposure, Mary Freshwater passed away on January 17, 2013,” and the causal relationship is “at least as likely as not.” That is the pleading; it has not, in these sources, been tested.
What the institution did afterward
For the Freshwater family, the afterward is measured most precisely in what did not exist.
It did not warn them. The complaint pleads it as a general fact of the base: “At no time did Defendant warn the individuals at the base or those coming onto the base that would be reasonably expected to use that water, that said water supply could and/or would potentially harm them and their families.” The Marine Corps, the complaint states, first discovered the contamination in the early 1980s “but did not inform veterans, their families, and civilian employees aboard Camp Lejeune about the contaminated wells until years later.” Even the discovery came after both sons were dead; the telling came years after that.
It provided no claim route and no remedy for family members. Veterans had, at least, the VA: a disability system, however adversarial, in which a Marine could file. Family members were not veterans. A mother in Tarawa Terrace housing had no VA claim to file and no court to go to.
Her daughter tried the one door that existed. The complaint records that on October 17, 2012, Lori Freshwater filed an administrative claim with the United States Navy, individually and on behalf of herself and Mary Freshwater. The Navy denied the claim, or — the complaint pleads in the alternative — it was constructively denied because the Navy failed to dispose of it within six months. Mary died three months after that filing, on January 17, 2013. The administrative claim was the only door, and it opened onto nothing.
The first statute addressed to families arrived in between. The Janey Ensminger Act — the Lejeune title of the Honoring America’s Veterans and Caring for Camp Lejeune Families Act, signed August 6, 2012 — for the first time made VA health care available to family members who had resided at Camp Lejeune for at least thirty days, for any of fifteen covered conditions, leukemia among them. It was care, not compensation: no damages for a dead child, no day in court. For Mary it arrived five months before her death; the damages statute arrived nine years after it.
Lori Freshwater spent the intervening years becoming the record-keeper her family’s case required — an investigative journalist who, in her counsel’s words, “has spent more than a decade researching the brutal losses experienced not only by her family, but by many others.” On August 10, 2022, the day the Camp Lejeune Justice Act was signed into law as part of the PACT Act, her counsel — Napoli Shkolnik, eLaw Firm PLLC, and Greg Jones Law, P.A. — filed notices of claim under the new Act on behalf of Lori, her late mother, and her late baby brother Rusty. Her statement that day is the center of this page:
“Today I am finally able to fulfill my mother’s fervent desire to have her day in court – not only to seek justice – but to ensure her immense suffering is not forgotten. In the documentary, Semper Fi: Always Faithful, as my mother held a small cardboard box filled with all she had left of my baby brother’s short life she said: We are not numbers in a study. We are human beings that have had great tragedies. In 2013, my mother lost her own life from Leukemia, and I was left with two cardboard boxes, the baby’s box and one containing her ashes. I am filing today for my little brother Rusty, my mom, and to try and change the behavior of polluters to make the world a safer place for the grandchildren my mother loved so very deeply.”
Three weeks later, on August 31, 2022, she filed the complaint itself: Freshwater v. United States, No. 7:22-cv-00161, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina, brought by Lori Lynn Freshwater individually and as executor of the Estate of Mary Freshwater, solely under Section 804(b) of the Camp Lejeune Justice Act. It sought damages for the harm the water allegedly caused, and demanded a jury trial. Counsel’s announcement framed the objects as compensation for the wrongful deaths of Mary Freshwater and Rusty Thorpe, and for the pain and suffering of Lori Freshwater.
Where it stands now
The documented record in the sources for this page ends on August 31, 2022, with the filing of the complaint, and this page will not pretend otherwise. As of that record: the claim that did not exist in Mary’s lifetime had been filed in her name by her daughter, under a statute nine years too late for the woman whose estate it pleads; the allegations stood as pleadings, framed to the Justice Act’s “at least as likely as not” standard. No outcome of the Freshwater suit appears in the sources for this page, and none is claimed here.
What the dates establish is the shape of the delay this wall exists to document. Rusty Thorpe lived from November 30, 1977 to January 1, 1978. Charles Thorpe lived one day, February 17, 1979. Their mother carried their losses, unwarned and without remedy, for thirty-five years. The damages route opened in August 2022 — forty-five years after her first son’s birth, nine years after her own death — and the person who walked through it was the daughter, carrying two cardboard boxes. Their names are on this wall because the institution that housed the family and supplied its water gave the mother no forum in her lifetime — and because her daughter, in the end, filed her mother’s case posthumously, as an inheritance.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- August 6, 2012: The Janey Ensminger Act, within the Honoring America’s Veterans and Caring for Camp Lejeune Families Act of 2012, made VA health care available for the first time to Lejeune family members with any of fifteen covered conditions, leukemia among them — five months before Mary Freshwater’s death.
- August 10, 2022: The Camp Lejeune Justice Act of 2022 (Section 804 of the PACT Act) created the first damages route for Lejeune family members; that same day, counsel for Lori Freshwater filed notices of claim under it on behalf of Lori, her late mother, and her late baby brother Rusty.
- August 31, 2022: Lori Lynn Freshwater filed suit in the Eastern District of North Carolina (No. 7:22-cv-00161), individually and as executor of the Estate of Mary Freshwater, seeking damages for the harm the complaint alleges the water caused, with a jury trial demand.
What has not been done
- No warning reached the family in time to matter: the complaint pleads the government never warned base residents the water could harm them, and the Marine Corps’ own discovery came in the early 1980s — after both sons were dead.
- No compensation or court route existed for family members in Mary’s lifetime: the 2012 act provided health care, not damages; Lori’s October 17, 2012 administrative claim to the Navy was denied or constructively denied; the damages statute arrived on August 10, 2022, nine years after Mary’s death.
- The family’s causation claims have never been adjudicated in the sources for this page: the neural tube defects, the miscarriage, and Mary’s leukemias are alleged in the 2022 complaint under the Act’s “at least as likely as not” standard — not found by any court.
What is being sought
- Judgment and damages under the Camp Lejeune Justice Act for the harm to Mary Freshwater and Lori Freshwater alleged in the August 31, 2022 complaint — framed by counsel as compensation for the wrongful deaths of Mary Freshwater and Rusty Thorpe, and for Lori Freshwater’s own pain and suffering.
- In Lori Freshwater’s words on the day the route opened, her mother’s “fervent desire to have her day in court – not only to seek justice – but to ensure her immense suffering is not forgotten.”
Sources
- Complaint, Freshwater v. United States, No. 7:22-cv-00161-M-RN (E.D.N.C., filed August 31, 2022) — the primary source for this page: Lori Lynn Freshwater, individually and as executor of the Estate of Mary Freshwater, suing solely under Section 804(b) of the Camp Lejeune Justice Act; Mary Freshwater born May 27, 1944, died January 17, 2013; the Tarawa Terrace record (PCE above the federal limit for 346 months, November 1957–February 1987; 104 ppb in July 1982; 215 ppb in February 1985); “at no time did Defendant warn the individuals at the base”; Mary’s diagnosis list, including “loss of child due to birth defect – born without cranium (Charles Warner Thorpe (born and died 2/17/79),” “loss of child due to spina bifida (born 11-30-77; died 1-1-78),” “miscarriage of twins, acute myeloid leukemia, and adult acute lymphoblastic leukemia”; the October 17, 2012 administrative claim to the Navy; the demand for judgment, damages, and a jury trial: https://ia601406.us.archive.org/8/items/gov.uscourts.nced.196116/gov.uscourts.nced.196116.1.0.pdf
- Napoli Shkolnik, eLaw Firm PLLC, and Greg Jones Law, P.A., “File Notices of Claim Under the Camp Lejeune Justice Act of 2022 on Behalf of Lori Freshwater and Her Family,” Business Wire, August 10, 2022 — the same-day claim filing on behalf of Lori L. Freshwater, her late mother Mary W. Freshwater (Thorpe), and her late baby brother, Alexander Russell (“Rusty”) Thorpe; the allegation that the contamination caused two baby boys (Rusty and Charlie) to develop fatal neural tube defects, “as well as two miscarriages borne by Mary Freshwater, who ultimately died from complications of two types of acute leukemia” (framed here against the complaint’s “miscarriage of twins”); Lori Freshwater’s statement, including the two cardboard boxes; the suit’s stated objects: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220810005500/en/Napoli-Shkolnik-eLaw-Firm-PLLC-and-Greg-Jones-Law-P.A.-File-Notices-of-Claim-Under-the-Camp-Lejeune-Justice-Act-of-2022-on-Behalf-of-Lori-Freshwater-and-Her-Family
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.