Gary J. Clendening: Three Courts, Three Dismissals, and No Hearing on the Merits
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Gary Clendening was a Marine lawyer — an officer in the Judge Advocate Division. He lived and worked at Hadnot Point, Camp Lejeune, from May 1970 to December 1971, drinking the water the base provided, and he died on November 16, 2016, after a years-long battle with adult leukemia, Waldenstrom macroglobulinemia, and chronic lymphoblastic lymphoma. His widow Carol alleged that Camp Lejeune's contaminated water caused his death, and she filed, she appealed, she petitioned the Supreme Court. Three courts considered her case. Not one of them ever reached the question of whether the water killed her husband. Each dismissed her on jurisdictional grounds that had nothing to do with causation. This page is the record of his service, his death, and the three closed doors, told from the opinions the courts themselves issued.
The service, and the promise
The facts of Gary Clendening’s service, as the Fourth Circuit recited them, are taken from his widow’s complaint. “From May 1970 to December 1971,” the court wrote, Clendening “resided at Camp Lejeune while serving as a United States Marine Officer in the Judge Advocate Division of the Marine Corps. Clendening lived in the Hadnot Point area of the base, located near the Hadnot Point Fuel Farm, a former incinerator and landfill.”
Nineteen months, then, at the main side of the base, beside the fuel farm whose tanks, the complaint alleged, began to leak and contaminate the water supply. The Hadnot Point system is the one the federal health agencies later reconstructed as the more heavily contaminated of Camp Lejeune’s two great water systems — primarily trichloroethylene (TCE), along with PCE, benzene, and vinyl chloride, at levels modeled as exceeding federal limits from 1953 into 1985 — a window his 1970–1971 tour sits squarely inside.
A JAG officer’s profession is the proposition that the institution governs itself by law — that process is not a courtesy but an obligation. Clendening spent those nineteen months inside the division charged with that proposition, drinking water his own institution supplied. The record shows what the proposition was worth when his widow later tried to use the law against that institution: the law, as the courts applied it, would not let her case be heard at all.
What happened
The Fourth Circuit’s opinion states the end of his life in one sentence, and this page will not improve on its plainness: “On November 16, 2016, Gary Clendening lost his years-long battle against adult leukemia, Waldenstrom macroglobulinemia, and chronic lymphoblastic lymphoma.”
Three diseases, fought for years. The opinion, following the complaint, records what his widow claimed caused them: that his death “resulted from his constant exposure, while stationed on active military duty at Camp Lejeune, to contaminated water and ‘radioactive waste, chemical weapon waste, solvents, benzene, and other carcinogens that were improperly disposed, buried or spilled at’ the base.” The complaint’s account, as the opinion recites it, included the leaking Fuel Farm tanks; the government’s awareness of the leakage by 1980, with no warnings issued; strontium-90 pellets found buried near where he had been stationed, with elevated levels confirmed in 1981 and still no action to inform exposed personnel; benzene found in a Hadnot Point drinking well in 1984; and, by 1985, the shutdown of all identified contaminated wells in the Hadnot Point network.
Every word of that account must carry its label, because the courts were careful with theirs: it is alleged. It comes from Carol Clendening’s complaint, recited by the Fourth Circuit as complaints are recited — as the plaintiff’s version, assumed only to decide whether the case could proceed at all. No court tested it. No court heard evidence on whether the water caused his leukemia, his macroglobulinemia, or his lymphoma. Justice Thomas used the same word in the Supreme Court: Gary Clendening “allegedly was exposed to toxins and contaminated water. He later died of leukemia.” Allegedly is not a small word in this record. It is the whole record, on causation — a claim carried through three courts and never once adjudicated.
One distinction belongs here: the only place any institution connected his disease to his exposure by rule rather than by allegation. The Fourth Circuit’s opinion recounts that in 2016 — the year of his death — the Department of Veterans Affairs adopted regulations stating that eight associated diseases, adult leukemia among them, were presumed to have been caused by exposure at Camp Lejeune. A VA presumption is a benefits rule; it binds no court. But it stands beside the dismissals: for benefits purposes, the government presumed the connection in the year he died of it, while in court it argued his widow could not even ask the question.
What the institution did afterward
In 2019, two and a half years after her husband’s death, Carol V. Clendening, as personal representative of his estate, sued the United States in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina under the Federal Tort Claims Act. Her complaint alleged fraudulent and “willfully and wantonly negligent” conduct in exposing personnel to dangerous chemicals and in the subsequent failure to warn; fraudulent concealment; and wrongful death due to water contamination.
The government’s answer was not a defense of the water. It was a motion to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, on two grounds: the Feres doctrine — the rule of Feres v. United States, 340 U.S. 135 (1950), that the government is not liable under the Tort Claims Act for injuries to servicemen arising out of activity incident to service — and the Act’s discretionary-function exception, 28 U.S.C. § 2680(a). On June 19, 2020, the district court dismissed all of her claims. She appealed. She carried the case as the estate’s personal representative through three courts over three years.
The Fourth Circuit decided the appeal on November 30, 2021 — Clendening v. United States, 19 F.4th 421 — and affirmed. On Feres, its reasoning was as broad as the doctrine: the exposure “occurred in the course of his day-to-day, active-duty service while on base at Camp Lejeune,” and “the military’s provision of water and accommodations to its troops is clearly activity incident to service.” Drinking the base’s water was, legally, an incident of being a Marine, which meant the Tort Claims Act did not reach it. The government’s blameworthiness was irrelevant; the doctrine bars intentional-tort claims as readily as negligence.
She asked the Fourth Circuit to overrule or abridge Feres itself. The court refused, in words the Supreme Court’s dissent would later quote: “To be sure, criticism of the Feres doctrine abounds. Justices, judges, and scholars have routinely noted the harsh results brought about by the doctrine, and many have suggested Feres itself was wrongly decided.” But the court of appeals is bound by it, and must leave “to [the Supreme] Court the prerogative of overruling its own decisions.”
One claim was treated separately. Her failure-to-warn claim — that the government had a duty to warn him, even after discharge, as it learned more over the years — was one the government conceded Feres did not bar, and the court agreed. It died on the second ground instead: the discretionary-function exception, because no mandatory duty removed the warning decision from the realm of government discretion. Affirmed, in full. Not a witness heard, not a causation finding made, on any claim.
Carol Clendening petitioned the Supreme Court. On November 7, 2022, the Court denied certiorari in Clendening v. United States, No. 21-1410. What the day produced was a dissent — Justice Thomas, dissenting from the denial of certiorari — the closest thing to a hearing her case ever received. “We should accept the invitation,” Thomas wrote. “As I have explained several times, Feres should be overruled.” The Act, he argued, renders the United States liable to all persons, including servicemen, and excepts only claims arising out of combatant activities during time of war: “Nothing in the Act bars suits by servicemen based on their military status alone.” Feres was an “atextual, policy-based carveout” that “heartily deserves the widespread, almost universal criticism it has received.” “Congress set out a comprehensive scheme waiving sovereign immunity that we have disregarded in the military context for nearly 75 years. Because we caused this chaos, it is our job to fix it.”
The Court did not fix it. The dissent was one justice’s. The denial stood, and her lawsuit ended where the district court had ended it in 2020 — dismissed, on jurisdiction, without a merits hearing.
Three months before that denial, Congress had acted on a different track. On August 10, 2022, the Camp Lejeune Justice Act of 2022 was signed as Section 804 of the PACT Act (Public Law 117-168) — a Lejeune-specific damages cause of action that the Tort Claims Act, as Feres construed it, had never allowed. Thomas noted it in a footnote, precisely: the Justice Act “does not alter the availability of recovery under the FTCA. Rather, the Act provides an alternative remedy to the FTCA that presupposes multiple routes to recovery,” and one “much narrower in scope than the FTCA.” The route arrived from the legislature, not the courts — after his death and after his widow’s suit.
Where it stands now
As of the record in the sources for this page, the Clendening litigation is over, and its ending is exact. The dismissal of June 19, 2020 stands. The affirmance of November 30, 2021 stands. The denial of certiorari of November 7, 2022 stands, with Justice Thomas’s dissent as its only published commentary. Feres stands. No court has found that Camp Lejeune’s water caused Gary Clendening’s death, and no court has found that it did not; the question was never within any court’s reach, because each court held, in turn, that it had no jurisdiction to ask it. That is the finding this page exists to record: the absence of any verdict at all.
The Justice Act changed the landscape after the fact. From August 10, 2022, a person exposed to Lejeune’s water for at least thirty days between August 1, 1953, and December 31, 1987 — his nineteen months at Hadnot Point fall within it — or that person’s legal representative, could claim with the Navy and, on denial or six months’ inaction, sue in the Eastern District of North Carolina under an “at least as likely as not” causation standard, within a two-year filing window. Whether Carol Clendening re-filed under the Justice Act is not in the sources for this page, and this page does not claim she did, or that she did not, or that she was or was not compensated under it. What the sources establish is narrower: during her husband’s lifetime and throughout her three-court fight, that route did not exist, and the route that did exist was held closed to her because the man who drank the water had been a Marine when he drank it.
What remains is the dissent. A sitting justice took Gary Clendening’s case as the vehicle to argue that the doctrine barring his widow’s suit should be overruled root and branch, and the Court let the bar stand without a word. His name is on this wall because his widow proved the exact shape of the wall itself: a Marine could be presumed by his own government, for benefits, to have died of a Lejeune disease, and simultaneously be barred by that same government, for damages, from ever having a court decide whether he did.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- 2019: Carol V. Clendening, as personal representative of the Estate of Gary J. Clendening, sued the United States under the Federal Tort Claims Act (E.D.N.C. No. 7:19-cv-00137-BR), alleging wrongful death from water contamination, fraudulent concealment, and failure to warn.
- November 30, 2021: The Fourth Circuit, having noted that “criticism of the Feres doctrine abounds,” left its overruling to the Supreme Court and affirmed the dismissal.
- November 7, 2022: Justice Thomas, dissenting from the denial of certiorari, stated on the record of the Supreme Court that Feres “should be overruled” and that the Court, having “caused this chaos,” bore the job of fixing it.
- August 10, 2022: Congress enacted the Camp Lejeune Justice Act (Section 804 of the PACT Act, Public Law 117-168), creating the Lejeune-specific damages route that had not existed at Gary Clendening’s death in 2016 or during his widow’s suit.
What has not been done
- No court ever reached causation. Every disposition was on jurisdictional grounds: Feres for the exposure claims, the discretionary-function exception for the failure-to-warn claim. The word the courts used for the water’s role in his death, from first to last, was “allegedly.”
- Feres was not overruled. The Supreme Court denied certiorari without reasoning; the call to reconsider it stands in a single justice’s dissent.
- The failure-to-warn claim — the one claim the government conceded Feres did not bar — was never heard either; it was held barred by the discretionary-function exception.
What is being sought
- What Carol Clendening sought from 2019 to 2022 and never received: a hearing on the merits — a court’s determination of whether the water Gary Clendening drank at Hadnot Point caused the diseases that killed him.
- What Justice Thomas’s dissent sought: reconsideration and overruling of Feres v. United States, so the Tort Claims Act’s waiver of sovereign immunity applies to servicemen as its text provides.
- The route Congress substituted in 2022 remains the only damages avenue the record shows for claims like his estate’s; whether his estate pursued it is not established in these sources.
Sources
- Clendening v. United States, 19 F.4th 421 (4th Cir. 2021) (No. 20-1878, decided November 30, 2021) — the primary source for this page: the facts taken from Carol Clendening’s complaint (Judge Advocate Division service, May 1970–December 1971, Hadnot Point residence; his death on November 16, 2016, after a years-long battle against adult leukemia, Waldenstrom macroglobulinemia, and chronic lymphoblastic lymphoma — the opinion’s wording, followed here); the 2016 VA presumption of eight diseases, adult leukemia among them, as recited in the opinion; the June 19, 2020 dismissal (No. 7:19-CV-137-BR); Feres applied because “the military’s provision of water and accommodations to its troops is clearly activity incident to service”; the failure-to-warn claim held barred by the discretionary-function exception: https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/Opinions/201878.P.pdf
- Clendening v. United States, 598 U.S. ___ (2022) (No. 21-1410, decided November 7, 2022) — the denial of certiorari and Justice Thomas’s dissent: Gary Clendening “allegedly was exposed to toxins and contaminated water. He later died of leukemia”; Feres as an “atextual, policy-based carveout”; the call to overrule it; the footnote that the Camp Lejeune Justice Act of 2022 provides an alternative remedy and does not alter FTCA recovery: https://Www.Supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1410_nkp1.pdf
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.