Harry Lew: The Marine His Own Squad Punished All Night, and the Aunt Who Carried His Name Into Law
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Harry Lew was twenty-one years old, and he was a Marine on watch in Afghanistan. On the night of April 2–3, 2011, after he was found asleep at his post, his fellow Marines put him through three and a half hours of what they called "corrective training" — berating, forced exercises in full body armor with a 25-pound sandbag, punches, kicks, and sand poured over his face and into his mouth. Twenty-two minutes after it ended, he was dead by his own hand in the foxhole he had been made to dig. This page is the documented record of that night, of what the courts-martial that followed decided and did not decide, and of what his aunt, a member of Congress, has forced into law and is still forcing — told in dates, verdicts, and the record's own words.
The service, and the promise
Harry Lew was from Santa Clara, California. He graduated from Santa Clara High School in 2008 and enlisted in the Marine Corps in August 2009. By April 2011 he was a lance corporal deployed to Afghanistan, holding Patrol Base Gowragi in the Nawa district of Helmand Province — a small, exposed patrol base in a war where falling asleep on watch could get a whole squad killed, a fact no one in this record disputes.
The promise made to a Marine like Harry Lew runs in both directions, and that is what makes this case an institutional failure rather than only a private tragedy. He owed his squad his alertness, and the record shows he failed at it more than once: by the accounts given at the trials that followed, he had fallen asleep on watch four times. His squad and his chain of command owed him correction inside the law of the service — discipline imposed by authority, proportioned to the offense, aimed at making a better Marine. Punishment administered by peers, in the dark, for hours, is not that system. His aunt, Rep. Judy Chu of California, later wrote the sentence that frames this page: Harry “wanted nothing more than to protect our country.” What the institution owed a 21-year-old who had volunteered for that — including when he failed at his post — is the question the rest of this record answers.
What happened
On the night of April 2, 2011, Lew was on guard duty at Patrol Base Gowragi and did not respond to calls on his radio. Rep. Chu’s account, published by her office from the record of the case, fixes the opening moments: at 11:15 p.m., his sergeant found him asleep on duty and cursed at him loudly enough to wake the rest of the Marines, announcing, in the words reported from that night, that “peers should correct peers.”
At 12:01 a.m. on April 3, what Chu’s office calls the hazing onslaught began. His fellow Marines took it on themselves to administer what they called “corrective training.” For three and a half hours, by the documented accounts Chu has repeated in testimony, in press releases, and on the House record for more than a decade, they:
- berated him and ordered him to dig a foxhole;
- forced him to perform exercises — pushups, crunches, leg lifts and planks among them — while wearing his heavy full body armor and carrying a 25-pound sandbag;
- stomped on his back, kicked him, and punched him; and
- poured the entire contents of a sandbag onto his face and into his mouth.
The abuse did not stop until about 3:21 a.m. — the trials later fixed the end of the session at roughly 3:20 a.m. At 3:43 a.m., twenty-two minutes after it ended, Harry Lew climbed into the fighting position he had just dug, leaned over his M249 Squad Automatic Weapon, and killed himself. He was 21 years old. A note was found written on his arm: “May hate me now, but in the long run this was the right choice I’m sorry my mom deserves the truth.”
The Department of Defense’s first public word on his death, released April 4, said only that he had died while supporting combat operations in Helmand Province. The circumstances — the hours of abuse that immediately preceded the shot — were not in it. They became public months later, through reporting on the Marine Corps’ own investigation.
Two parts of this record are contested, and this page states them the way the record states them — side by side, labeled.
The family’s position is Rep. Chu’s, stated by her consistently since 2011: that the hazing caused her nephew’s death — that an upset sergeant set two lance corporals on him, that they assaulted him for three and a half hours, and that Harry “commit[ted] suicide 20 minutes later” because of what was done to him. The family attended the trials in Hawaii. Chu has never qualified that position.
The official findings are narrower. None of the three Marines was charged with responsibility for Lew’s death; the charges concerned the treatment, not the death. In the first case resolved, the military judge stated that she saw no evidence the abuse led to the suicide. And the juries that tried the other two Marines acquitted them outright — in Lance Cpl. Carlos Orozco III’s case, the panel concluded that his disciplinary measures were not out of line and did not warrant punishment. Those are the findings of record. The family’s account is also of record. This page does not reconcile them; it reports both, because the gap between them is itself part of the accounting.
What the institution did afterward
Three Marines were charged in connection with that night, and their cases were tried at Marine Corps Base Hawaii at Kaneohe Bay. The results, in the order they concluded:
- Lance Cpl. Jacob D. Jacoby — the Marine Chu’s office described as the one who “did most of the hazing” — resolved his case by plea agreement. On January 30, 2012, he pleaded guilty to assault, admitting in court that he had punched and kicked Lew. His sentence was 30 days of confinement and reduction in rank to private first class. Chu’s office, and her later congressional testimony, return to that figure again and again: “only one of his three attackers was convicted of any wrongdoing, for which he was sentenced to only 30 days in confinement.”
- Sgt. Benjamin Johns, Lew’s squad leader, was tried next and acquitted of all charges. The defense position, which the jury accepted, was that Johns had not ordered or carried out the overnight session. Chu answered the verdict in a press release the next day: “It was an upset Sgt. Johns that led two lance corporals, Harry’s peers, to take matters into their own hands and assault him for 3½ hours, leading Harry to commit suicide 20 minutes later. Yet the military does not hold Sgt. Johns responsible for any of this.”
- Lance Cpl. Carlos Orozco III, accused of assault, cruelty and maltreatment, and humiliating Lew — including forcing leg lifts and pushups and pouring sand on his face — was tried last. On February 24, 2012, a military jury acquitted him on all counts, the final verdict in the case.
Rep. Chu attended the trials. Her verdict on the verdicts has not changed in the years since, and she repeated it under the heading of congressional testimony in April 2014: three Marines charged, two acquitted, one convicted of assault alone, thirty days.
The second institutional failure was quieter, and in its way larger. When Harry Lew died, the Department of Defense did not track hazing in any consistent, department-wide way. Chu testified in 2014 that most branches did not track allegations or incidents of hazing separately from similar offenses such as assault and bullying — the Air Force, she noted, had arrived at its count of hazing investigations since 2000 by searching a legal database for the word “haze” and its derivatives — and that the only two branches that did not require hazing to be reported at all were the Army and the Marine Corps, which, not surprisingly, reported the higher numbers. In Harry’s own unit, she told the House Armed Services Subcommittee on Military Personnel, there had been six cases of hazing in the year before his death. An institution that does not count a thing cannot be said, on the record, to be preventing it.
Where it stands now
What followed Harry Lew’s death was not a Marine Corps reform program. It was his aunt’s legislative campaign, sustained across more than a decade, and the record of it is specific.
In 2012, Chu called for a congressional hearing on military hazing. The hearing that followed — “Hazing in the Military,” before the House Armed Services Subcommittee on Military Personnel — was the first congressional hearing on military hazing since 1979, and, in Chu’s words, may have been the first official hearing to examine hazing across every branch of the Armed Forces.
The same year she introduced the Harry Lew Military Hazing Accountability and Prevention Act. Its provisions were enacted as part of the Fiscal Year 2013 National Defense Authorization Act: Chu’s amendment required each military branch to provide thorough reports on its hazing policies, its procedures for tracking and reporting incidents, and its training practices, and the FY2013 act’s language required the Department of Defense to report to Congress the manner in which hazing is reported, tracked, and prevented by each branch. In May 2013, the Marine Corps instituted a new hazing policy.
Chu then secured an amendment to the FY2015 NDAA requiring an independent review by the Government Accountability Office. The GAO report, released in February 2016, found that the Department of Defense lacked consistent data on hazing incidents, that its guidance was unclear and imperfectly applied, that anti-hazing policies were not being implemented, and that tracking systems across the services were highly divergent and underdeveloped. Chu’s summary, introducing a renewed version of the Harry Lew Act in 2016, is the finding in one sentence: “Today we have an independent analysis that found that the Defense Department’s anti-hazing policies are not being implemented, training is unclear and tracking systems are highly divergent and underdeveloped.”
The fight did not end there, because the central demand was never met: hazing was still not a standalone crime under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. In the most recent Congress, Chu — joined by Rep. Jill Tokuda and Rep. Dan Goldman in the House and Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand in the Senate — introduced the Harry Lew and Danny Chen Military Justice Reform Act, named for her nephew and for Army Pvt. Danny Chen, who died by suicide in Afghanistan in October 2011 after physical abuse and racist hazing by his superiors. The bill would require the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice to analyze and report to Congress on whether the military justice code should contain a standalone crime for hazing.
And the ground has shifted under the gains that were made. On September 30, 2025, Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth announced sweeping changes to how the military handles allegations of hazing and other abuse. On October 10, 2025, Chu led 27 members of Congress in a letter urging him to withdraw those changes, uphold the Department’s statutory reporting requirements, and strengthen protections for service members. Her statement restated the whole case: “For 3.5 hours, his peers berated him, stomped on his back, kicked and punched him, and poured the entire contents of a sandbag onto his face and in his mouth. Just 22 minutes after the abuse ended, Harry took his own life. He was only 21 years old.”
Harry Lew’s name is now on legislation in two forms — an accountability act whose reporting provisions became law in 2013, and a justice reform act still seeking the standalone crime his family has demanded since 2012. The patrol base is long closed. The accounting his aunt opened the week he died is not.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- Three Marines were charged and brought to court-martial at Marine Corps Base Hawaii for the treatment of Harry Lew on the night of April 2–3, 2011.
- Lance Cpl. Jacob D. Jacoby pleaded guilty to assault on January 30, 2012, and was sentenced to 30 days of confinement and reduction in rank to private first class.
- The first congressional hearing on military hazing since 1979 was held in 2012, at Rep. Chu’s demand, examining hazing across every branch of the Armed Forces.
- Provisions of the Harry Lew Military Hazing Accountability and Prevention Act were enacted in the FY2013 National Defense Authorization Act, requiring each service to report on its hazing policies, tracking and reporting procedures, and training, and requiring DoD to report to Congress on how hazing is reported, tracked, and prevented.
- The Marine Corps instituted a new hazing policy in May 2013.
- A Government Accountability Office review, required by Chu’s amendment to the FY2015 NDAA and released in February 2016, examined DoD hazing policies, tracking, and training across the services — and documented, independently, that the data did not exist in consistent form, the guidance was unclear, and the tracking systems were divergent and underdeveloped.
What has not been done
- Sgt. Benjamin Johns was acquitted of all charges, and Lance Cpl. Carlos Orozco III was acquitted of all charges on February 24, 2012. Of three Marines charged, one was convicted — of assault, not hazing — and served 30 days.
- No defendant was charged with responsibility for Lew’s death, and the military judge in the first case stated she saw no evidence the abuse led to the suicide. The family’s position — that the hazing caused his death — has never been adopted by any official finding.
- Hazing is still not a standalone crime under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. That was Chu’s demand in 2012; more than a decade later, the Harry Lew and Danny Chen Military Justice Reform Act asks only that the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice study and report on whether it should be.
- The department-wide tracking the FY2013 act was meant to produce had still not materialized when the GAO reported in February 2016 — five years after Lew’s death — and on September 30, 2025, the Department of Defense moved, in Chu’s characterization, to roll back the hazing protections that did exist.
What is being sought
- A standalone crime of hazing in the military justice code — sought by Chu and the Tri-Caucus chairs since April 2012, and now the subject of the Harry Lew and Danny Chen Military Justice Reform Act’s required Joint Service Committee analysis and report to Congress.
- A national database of hazing incidents and annual reporting to Congress — demanded in the family’s April 3, 2012 letter to the House Armed Services Committee and carried in the Harry Lew Act as reintroduced, so that, in Chu’s words, Congress can see whether the actions are working.
- Withdrawal of the September 30, 2025 Department of Defense policy changes on hazing and abuse, and full enforcement of the Department’s statutory hazing reporting requirements — the demand of the October 10, 2025 letter Chu led, signed by 27 members of Congress.
- The standard Chu set in her first hearing, and has repeated since: that there be a consequence for the troops who engage in hazing. On the record of her nephew’s case, there was, in total, thirty days.
Sources
- Rep. Judy Chu, “Military Hazing,” chu.house.gov — Chu’s account of her nephew’s death (three and a half hours of “corrective training,” the 25-pound sandbag, death 22 minutes after the abuse ended), the 2012 hearing, the FY2013 NDAA amendment, and the September–October 2025 rollback and letter: https://chu.house.gov/issues/military-hazing
- Rep. Judy Chu, “Rep. Chu Praises Passage of NDAA & Military Hazing Prevention Policies,” chu.house.gov — the detailed timeline (found asleep April 3, 2011; sergeant at 11:15 p.m.; the session beginning 12:01 a.m.; death at 3:43 a.m.) and the Harry Lew Military Hazing Accountability and Prevention Act of 2012 provisions: https://chu.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/rep-chu-praises-passage-ndaa-military-hazing-prevention-policies
- Rep. Judy Chu, “Congresswoman Chu Decries Not Guilty Verdict in Marine Hazing Case,” chu.house.gov — the acquittal of Sgt. Benjamin Johns, the Jacoby sentence, Chu’s attendance and response, and the family’s causation position: https://chu.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/congresswoman-chu-decries-not-guity-verdict-marine-hazing-case
- Rep. Judy Chu, “Congresswoman Chu, Congressional Leaders Grill Military Over Ineffective Hazing Policies,” chu.house.gov — the 2012 “Hazing in the Military” hearing, the six hazing cases in Lew’s unit in the prior year, and the two acquittals and one-month sentence: https://chu.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/congresswoman-chu-congressional-leaders-grill-military-over-ineffective
- Rep. Judy Chu, Written Testimony for the House Armed Services Committee Regarding the FY2015 NDAA, April 7, 2014, chu.house.gov — the 30-day sentence, the FY2013 reporting language, the state of hazing tracking across the branches, and the Marine Corps’ May 2013 policy: https://chu.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/chu-evo.house.gov/files/documents/FY2015 NDAA Written Testimony of Congresswoman Judy Chu.pdf
- Rep. Judy Chu, “Rep. Chu Bill Requires Pentagon to Track, Report on Military Hazing,” chu.house.gov — the February 2016 GAO report’s findings on DoD’s inconsistent hazing data and unclear guidance, and the Harry Lew Act’s database and annual-report requirements: https://chu.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/rep-chu-bill-requires-pentagon-track-report-military-hazing
- Rep. Judy Chu, “Rep. Chu Condemns DOD’s Rollback of Military Hazing Protections,” chu.house.gov — the September 30, 2025 Hegseth policy changes and the October 10, 2025 letter from 27 members of Congress: http://chu.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/rep-chu-condemns-dods-rollback-military-hazing-protections
- Reps. Chu, Tokuda, Goldman and Sen. Gillibrand, “Introduce Military Hazing Reform Bill in Honor of Harry Lew and Danny Chen,” chu.house.gov — the Harry Lew and Danny Chen Military Justice Reform Act and its Joint Service Committee analysis requirement: http://chu.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/reps-chu-tokuda-goldman-and-sen-gillibrand-introduce-military-hazing
- Army Times, “Lawmakers to SecDef: End ‘racial-based’ hazing now,” May 4, 2015 — the Tri-Caucus letter of May 1, 2015 to Secretary Carter, and Lew’s death in April 2011 after hours of abuse for falling asleep on watch: https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2015/05/04/lawmakers-to-secdef-end-racial-based-hazing-now/
- Army Times, “New military hazing rules could be part of annual defense bill,” March 1, 2016 — the GAO report’s findings, the three charged Marines, the single conviction and one month served, and Chu’s renewed demands: https://www.armytimes.com/news/pentagon-congress/2016/03/01/new-military-hazing-rules-could-be-part-of-annual-defense-bill/
- Nichi Bei News, Rep. Judy Chu, “Our country’s failure to stop hazing in the military,” March 2012 — the February 24, 2012 conclusion of the final court-martial, Orozco’s acquittal, Johns’s earlier acquittal, and Jacoby’s plea and sentence: https://www.nichibei.org/2012/03/our-countrys-failure-to-stop-hazing-in-the-military/
- JD Journal, “Hazing Ruled Not the Cause of Marine’s Suicide,” January 31, 2012 — Jacoby’s plea and 30-day sentence, the judge’s statement that she saw no evidence the abuse led to the suicide, the “peers should correct peers” order, the 3:43 a.m. account from Marine Corps Times reporting, and the note found on Lew’s arm: https://www.jdjournal.com/2012/01/31/hazing-ruled-not-the-cause-of-marines-suicide/amp/?p=36752
- Disappeared News (Honolulu), coverage of the Orozco and Johns courts-martial, February 2012 — Orozco’s acquittal on all counts, Johns’s acquittal, and the trial testimony and charges: http://www.disappearednews.com/2012/02/lance-cpl-orozco-found-not-guilty-of.html?m=0
- Character Media, “Congresswoman’s Nephew Commits Suicide After Marine Hazing Incident,” August 24, 2011 — the Marine Corps Times investigative account, Patrol Base Gowragi in Nawa district, the April 2–3 timeline, and the Defense Department’s initial April 4 announcement: https://charactermedia.com/congresswomans-nephew-commits-suicide-after-marine-hazing-incident/
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.