James C. McCloughan: The Medic Who Saved Ten Men and Waited 48 Years for the Medal
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
James C. McCloughan was a combat medic — "Doc" — to the men of Charlie Company, and over 48 hours at Nui Yon Hill in May 1969, wounded himself, he went into the kill zone again and again and saved at least ten of them. The decoration his platoon leader put him in for came back downgraded, with no explanation, and McCloughan told only two people — his father and his uncle — and then said nothing about it for forty years. This page is the documented record: what he did, what the Army gave him for it at the time, and what it finally took — his platoon leader, five witness statements, three rejections, a Secretary of Defense, an act of Congress, and two presidents — for the institution to award the medal its own review said he had earned in 1969.
The service, and the promise
James C. McCloughan grew up in Bangor, Michigan, where he fell in love with sports. In high school he was a four-sport varsity athlete, and he later made the wrestling, baseball, and football teams at Olivet College. Wanting to be a coach, he took courses in kinesiology, physiology, anatomy, and first aid — training that would decide what the Army did with him.
In 1968, three months after securing a job as a teacher-coach for a local high school, McCloughan got his draft notice. During basic training at Fort Knox, his background in sports medicine made his superiors think he was meant for the medical corps. “I felt lucky,” he later said. “I was a draftee, and usually you don’t get those kinds of jobs.” He received his orders as a medic with Company C, 3rd Battalion, 21st Infantry Regiment, 196th Light Infantry Brigade, Americal Division, in the Republic of Vietnam.
It was early 1969, at a peak of the war. “I thought it would be positive,” McCloughan said of his assignment, “to be trying to save lives in such a negative situation.” He learned how negative it could be on his first day in country: “We hit an ambush, lost two men, several injured, and I shot my first enemy soldier. That was my initiation into being a combat medic.”
The promise made to a soldier in his position is written into how the Army decorates its own: valor witnessed by your chain of command is to be recognized at the level the witnesses recommend, and if it is not, the soldier is entitled at least to know why. What the record shows here is a recommendation that went up, a lesser medal that came back, and — in both sources for this page — no explanation at all.
He rose to Specialist 5 before he left the service. The rank on his Medal of Honor citation is the one he held at Nui Yon Hill: Private First Class.
What happened
In mid-May 1969, during an air assault into an area near Tam Ky, south of Da Nang, helicopters ferrying Charlie Company — 89 men — came under small-arms and machine-gun fire as they were about to land. Two were shot down. Others, following standard procedure in a hot landing zone, hovered eight or ten feet off the ground while the men jumped.
The battle ran from May 13 to May 15, 1969, at Nui Yon Hill. Over 48 hours, by the documented count in his record, McCloughan entered the kill zone nine times. The Defense Department credits him with saving at least ten lives under fire while being wounded three times. The sequence, as The VVA Veteran reconstructed it from the men who were there:
- He joined a squad going out to rescue the pilot and crew of one of the downed helicopters, about a hundred meters away. They found a crewman too injured to move. McCloughan hoisted him over his shoulder and ran back with him the full distance, dodging fire from a nearby North Vietnamese Army force.
- In a trench, ducking fire from another ambush, he saw two wounded men hiding behind a bush, without weapons. He leapt out, ran to them, and dragged both back to safety amid enemy gunfire. Wounded himself in the process by rocket-propelled grenade shrapnel, he continued — four more times — to run into the kill zone and pull injured comrades into the trench, ignoring a direct order to stay put for his own safety.
- On the second day, another ambush killed the only other medic in the company. McCloughan was left as the company’s sole medic. Tending two wounded Americans in an open rice paddy, he was hit with more shrapnel. As two North Vietnamese companies and a Viet Cong regiment closed in with a deadly crossfire, he was up again, running exposed, to help the wounded.
- Air strikes kept the enemy at bay, but the company had to spend another night there. Just before dawn, McCloughan used a grenade to knock out an enemy rocket-propelled grenade position in between treating his comrades.
The Defense Department adds the resupply: when supplies ran low, McCloughan volunteered to wear a strobe light on his helmet so helicopters could drop supplies — a beacon for the helicopters, and, as Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis put it, “also a magnet for enemy rounds and rocket-propelled grenades.” The helicopters could not make it in.
His company commander saw his wounds and ordered the medic to evacuate. McCloughan’s reply, as Mattis recounted it, was: “They are going to need me.”
By the time it was over, he had saved ten men. Mattis put the odds the company faced at 28 to one, held off — with air and artillery support — over two full days. McCloughan assigned the credit the other way — he said he was holding the award as a tribute to the 89 men who fought at Nui Yon Hill.
What the institution did afterward
Randy Clark, McCloughan’s platoon leader, had seen his medic pull men to safety, though he did not realize at the time how many. “During the battle you don’t really have time to see what everybody’s doing all the time,” Clark said. “But I knew he’d saved a couple people. Jim did his job just like we all did a job, but he really did more than most. And of all the soldiers I’d ever served with, he was certainly the best. So I figured I’d put him in for a Silver Star.”
The recommendation went up to brigade. It came back with the decision to award a Bronze Star — with a “V” device, for valor. Clark got no explanation. What he remembered instead was the talk afterward: “the talk in the barracks afterward was, ‘Randy, you know, typically a grunt sort of guy, enlisted guys, it’s pretty unusual to give them a Silver Star.’”
That perception — that an enlisted medic’s rank, not his actions, set the ceiling on his decoration — is recorded here as what Clark and McCloughan themselves said it was: their experience of the decision, in their own words, not a finding by any review. McCloughan, who knew Clark had put in for a higher decoration, said: “I didn’t go to Vietnam for any medals. I really just wanted to come home, but I was taken aback by the prejudice.” He accepted the Bronze Star, came home, told only his father and his uncle about the episode, and went on with his life.
One compression in the official record should be noted: the Defense Department’s 2017 account states that McCloughan “was recommended for a Distinguished Service Cross, but that was downgraded to a Bronze Star with a Valor device.” The fuller account — Clark’s own, in The VVA Veteran — is that the original recommendation was for a Silver Star, and the Distinguished Service Cross was the level Clark chose when he revived the case forty years later. Both agree on what matters to the ledger: a higher recommendation went up, a Bronze Star came back, and no explanation was given.
Then the case sat for forty years. McCloughan retired from the teaching and coaching career he had always wanted — 40 years in the classroom and on the athletic field in South Haven, Michigan, touching, in Mattis’s words, 10,000 lives there. The revival began when his uncle came to him and said he knew someone in a Michigan congressman’s office and was going to ask for help getting his nephew properly recognized for his actions at Tam Ky.
McCloughan found Clark. Clark said he would be happy to try again, with a different strategy: “This time I’d put in for a Distinguished Service Cross, figuring they’d knock it down to a Silver Star.”
The process took eight years. Battle maps and witness statements had to accompany the submission, and multiple people from the former chain of command — including three retired generals — had to be tracked down to sign in original ink, one at a time, by mail; as Clark put it, the documents “went leap-frogging around the country.” The Army rejected the submission at least three times, each rejection requiring a redo of the entire process. On a later submission, about seven years in, everything was in order — and Clark was told one of the forms he had filled out was now obsolete. The Army had replaced it and had not told him.
In 2016 the Army finally deemed the paperwork acceptable and started its review. That October, McCloughan and his wife Cherie were in Denver, in an IHOP, when his cell phone rang. He did not recognize the number and ignored it; when the caller left a message, he put the phone on speaker, thinking he and his wife would get a laugh out of a desperate salesman. “It was Debbie Stabenow,” he said. “And her message was: ‘The exciting news is, your case came across the desk of [then-Secretary of Defense] Ashton Carter, and he said the DSC is not high enough. He has recommended you for the Medal of Honor.’ My wife and I were crying by that point.”
Carter had raised the award — the Distinguished Service Cross Clark had sought was, in the Secretary’s judgment, not high enough. Because the statutory time limit had long passed, Congress waived the time limit for McCloughan’s case. The Defense Department records the approval as coming at the end of December 2016. The presentation then waited through the change of administrations, and the medal was presented by the next president — a second long wait, four decades after the first, between what the institution had decided he earned and the day it put the medal in his hands.
Where it stands now
On July 31, 2017 — 48 years after Nui Yon Hill — President Donald J. Trump presented McCloughan with the Medal of Honor at the White House. Clark and more than a dozen other members of the platoon attended. “They did a bang-up job giving him the medal,” Clark said. “And they couldn’t have picked a better guy to give it to.”
The next day, August 1, 2017, McCloughan was inducted into the Pentagon’s Hall of Heroes, in a standing-room-only ceremony presided over by Secretary Mattis, Acting Army Secretary Robert M. Speer, Army Chief of Staff Gen. Mark Milley, and Sergeant Major of the Army Dan Dailey. Mattis told him: “I tell you sir, that while this honor is long overdue, it comes in earnest.” That same year, Vietnam Veterans of America made him a life member.
The record is now correct at the top: the citation carries the dates May 13–15, 1969, the unit, and the Army’s own standard for the medal — conspicuous gallantry and intrepidity at the risk of his life, above and beyond the call of duty. What no ceremony can correct is the interval: a Bronze Star in place of his platoon leader’s recommendation, no explanation in 1970 or in the forty years after, and a medal that arrived when its recipient was a retired teacher in his seventies rather than the 23-year-old medic who had earned it. McCloughan has offered his own account of the delay — there is another reason, he said, that it took nearly fifty years: “God has a plan.” That is his faith, recorded here as his. The institution’s reasons were never recorded, because the institution never gave any.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- Charlie Company revived the case in 2009. Platoon leader Randy Clark, prompted by McCloughan’s uncle, filed again — this time for the Distinguished Service Cross — assembled five witness statements and original signatures from the former chain of command, and resubmitted through at least three Army rejections over eight years.
- In October 2016, Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter raised the recommendation to the Medal of Honor, judging the Distinguished Service Cross not high enough. Congress waived the statutory time limit, and the award was approved at the end of December 2016, per the Defense Department.
- President Donald J. Trump presented the Medal of Honor on July 31, 2017, and McCloughan was inducted into the Pentagon Hall of Heroes on August 1, 2017. Vietnam Veterans of America made him a life member the same year.
What has not been done
- No explanation for the original downgrade was ever given. Clark received none when the Silver Star recommendation came back as a Bronze Star, and none appears in either source for this page covering the forty years that followed.
- The correction took 48 years, and most of them were silence. From the Bronze Star to Clark’s revival in 2009 was forty years in which the institution took no step of its own; the revival was begun by the veteran’s family and his platoon leader, not by the Army.
- Even after Carter’s 2016 decision and the December approval, the presentation waited until July 31, 2017, across a presidential transition.
What is being sought
- On this page, nothing further is pending for McCloughan himself: the medal his actions earned is awarded, cited, and entered in the Hall of Heroes. What is being sought is the accounting itself — that the downgrade with no explanation, and the forty silent years that followed it, stay on the record beside the medal, so the correction is not mistaken for the institution having worked as promised the first time.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Defense, “Pentagon Enshrines Medal of Honor Soldier in Hall of Heroes,” August 1, 2017 — the Hall of Heroes induction; at least ten lives saved, three wounds, the 28-to-one odds, and the Department’s summary of the downgrade and the 2009 revival: https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/1264082/pentagon-enshrines-medal-of-honor-soldier-in-hall-of-heroes/
- The VVA Veteran, Vietnam Veterans of America, “James McCloughan and the Medal of Honor That Surprised Everyone,” January–February 2019 (Vol. 38, No. 1) — Clark’s original Silver Star recommendation, the unexplained Bronze Star, the forty-year silence, the 2009 revival, and the October 2016 Denver IHOP call: https://vvaveteran.org/38-1/38-1_mccloughan.html
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.