Marcelino Serna: Every Major Award Short of the Medal of Honor — and the Medal Never Came
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Marcelino Serna was not an American citizen when he fought for the United States in France. The Army discovered the fact in the middle of the war and offered to send him home. He stayed. He then performed, twice over, the kind of single-handed actions the Medal of Honor exists to recognize — and he received every major decoration the United States and its allies could give him except that one. He died in 1992 still a private in the nation's memory. In 2021, the Legislature of Texas placed its finding in the official record: he was denied the supreme honor "only because he was a Mexican American immigrant and did not know enough English to be promoted." This page presents that record — the service, the decorations, and the Legislature's stated finding, labeled as what it is.
The service, and the promise
Marcelino Serna was born in Chihuahua, Mexico, in 1896. He came to the United States as a young man and spent time in Texas, Kansas, and Colorado. After the United States entered the First World War in 1917, he enlisted in the U.S. Army at the age of twenty. After only three weeks of training, he was shipped overseas with the 355th Infantry, 89th Division.
In France, his superior officers learned that he was not a U.S. citizen. They gave him the opportunity to return home — a lawful discharge from a war that was not, on paper, his country’s fight. Private Serna chose to stay and fight. That sentence, carried verbatim in the Texas Legislature’s 2021 resolution, is the whole case in miniature: at the one moment the institution offered him an honorable exit on the ground of his foreign birth, he waived it and went to the line. Nothing the Army later withheld from him can be separated from the fact that it had first offered to withhold the war itself, and he refused the offer.
What happened
The resolution of the 87th Texas Legislature, House Concurrent Resolution 71, records two actions.
Near St. Mihiel, twelve members of Serna’s unit were hit by fire from an enemy machine gun. Serna obtained his lieutenant’s permission to scout out the gun emplacement alone. Moving through heavy fire — and surviving two rounds that were deflected by his helmet — he threw four hand grenades into the machine-gun nest, killing six of the enemy, and then took the eight survivors captive, by himself.
Shortly afterward, during the Meuse-Argonne campaign, Serna undertook a second lone scouting mission. He wounded a German sniper with a shot from two hundred yards and followed the injured man into a trench. Firing and throwing grenades in all directions to make it seem as if he were part of a larger force, he shot three German soldiers, then attacked an enemy dugout, felling twenty-six more and capturing twenty-four — and held the prisoners at gunpoint, alone, until the rest of his unit arrived.
He continued in combat until the end of the war. He was wounded in both legs four days before the Armistice. While he was recovering in a French hospital, General John J. Pershing, the American commander in France, personally presented him with the Distinguished Service Cross, the nation’s second-highest military decoration. Serna was the first Mexican American awarded the Distinguished Service Cross.
The full list of his decorations, as the Texas Legislature recorded them: the Distinguished Service Cross; the World War I Victory Medal with five stars; the Victory Medal with three campaign bars; the St. Mihiel Medal; the Verdun Medal; two Purple Hearts; two French Croix de Guerre with Palm; the French Médaille Militaire; the French Commemorative Medal; the British Medal of Honor; and the Italian Cross of Merit. He was, in the resolution’s words, “one of the most decorated military veterans in Texas history” — among the most decorated Texas soldiers of the First World War by any honest reckoning, and by the Legislature’s account the most decorated Texas veteran of that war. He won every major military award short of the Medal of Honor.
What the institution did afterward
He was never promoted past private. And the Medal of Honor never came.
The reason is a matter of legislative record, and this page presents it exactly as that — the stated finding of a state legislature, entered in its official journal, not a court’s verdict. The 87th Legislature of the State of Texas resolved in 2021, in House Concurrent Resolution 71, that Serna won “every major military award short of the Congressional Medal of Honor, and records indicate that he was denied that supreme honor only because he was a Mexican American immigrant and did not know enough English to be promoted.” The resolution’s operative clause then “respectfully urge[s] the United States Congress to bestow on Marcelino Serna the Congressional Medal of Honor,” and directs the Texas secretary of state to forward official copies to the President, to the leaders of both houses of Congress, to the Secretary of Defense, and to the entire Texas delegation, with the request that the resolution be entered in the Congressional Record as a memorial to Congress.
Serna’s own postwar life ran on the ordinary track of a man the country had used and half-thanked. He became a U.S. citizen in 1924 — six years after he had fought for the country that had not yet claimed him — and settled in El Paso, where he worked for the quartermaster at Fort Bliss, was a charter member of Veterans of Foreign Wars Post No. 2753, and volunteered with veterans’ advocacy groups. He married and raised his family there. He died in 1992 and was buried with full military honors at Fort Bliss. The country he had chosen in 1918 buried him with honors in 1992. It had still not given him its medal.
The effort did not die with him; it changed hands. A congressional bill to award him the Medal of Honor, introduced in 1995, died in committee. The campaign is carried now by veterans’ organizations — the American GI Forum and LULAC among them — and by legislators pressing the case on his family’s behalf. And Texas, having urged the nation to act, acted itself. The Legislature’s direction of its own honor moved with a speed Washington has never matched: Senate Concurrent Resolution 50, directing the governor to award the Texas Legislative Medal of Honor to Serna posthumously, was adopted by the Texas Senate on May 21, 2021, by a vote of 31 to 0, and by the Texas House on May 29, 2021, by a vote of 140 to 0, and signed by the governor that June. The state’s highest military honor was presented to his family in 2022 — a state’s substitute, a century later, for the nation’s withheld one. The contrast is part of the record: a state legislature, presented with the same file, acted unanimously in a single session. The Congress of the United States has had the file since 1995.
Where it stands now
As of this writing, the Medal of Honor has still not come — more than a hundred years after St. Mihiel and the Meuse-Argonne, more than thirty years after Serna’s death, and years after the Texas Legislature put its finding and its formal request into the Congressional Record pipeline.
So the record stands in two columns that do not reconcile. In one: an immigrant private who was offered his discharge and refused it; who took a machine-gun nest alone with two bullet strikes on his helmet; who captured twenty-four men alone in the Argonne and held them at gunpoint; who was wounded in both legs in the war’s last week; who was decorated by the United States, France, Italy, and Britain — every major award short of one. In the other column: that one award, withheld, and a state legislature’s explanation for why, which no federal body has ever answered, rebutted, or acted on. The Texas finding may be advocacy as well as history — this page labels it as the Legislature’s stated finding, and no more — but the silence it addresses is a federal fact. Congress has the resolution. It has had bills since 1995. Private Serna is still waiting.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- The service and the decorations are official: the Distinguished Service Cross (presented by Gen. Pershing), two French Croix de Guerre with Palm, the Médaille Militaire, the Italian Cross of Merit, the British Medal of Honor, two Purple Hearts, and the campaign medals of the 355th Infantry, 89th Division — every major award short of the Medal of Honor.
- The 87th Texas Legislature (2021), in House Concurrent Resolution 71, stated its finding on the record — that Serna “was denied that supreme honor only because he was a Mexican American immigrant and did not know enough English to be promoted” — and formally urged Congress to bestow the Medal of Honor, directing copies to the President, Congress, and the Secretary of Defense.
- Texas awarded Serna its own Texas Legislative Medal of Honor in 2022.
What has not been done
- The Medal of Honor has never been awarded — not in 1918, not in his lifetime (he died in 1992), and not since. A 1995 congressional bill died in committee; HCR 71’s urging has produced no federal award.
- No federal body has answered the Texas Legislature’s stated finding — neither confirmed it, rebutted it, nor reviewed the case on the record it presents.
What is being sought
- The Medal of Honor itself, urged on Congress by the State of Texas and pressed by the American GI Forum, LULAC, and legislators on behalf of Serna’s family — nothing more than the one decoration his documented record has carried a claim to since 1918.
Sources
- Texas Legislature, House Concurrent Resolution 71, 87th Legislature (2021), engrossed text — Serna’s enlistment at 20, the offer of discharge in France on discovery of his non-citizenship and his choice to stay, the St. Mihiel and Meuse-Argonne actions, the Distinguished Service Cross presented by Gen. Pershing, the full list of his decorations, his 1924 naturalization and El Paso life, his death in 1992, and the Legislature’s finding that he “was denied that supreme honor only because he was a Mexican American immigrant and did not know enough English to be promoted,” with the resolution urging Congress to bestow the Medal of Honor: https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/87R/billtext/pdf/HC00071E.pdf
- Texas Senate Research Center, Bill Analysis, C.S.H.C.R. 71 (May 19, 2021) — the sponsor’s statement and the resolution text as reported by the Senate Committee on Veteran Affairs & Border Security: https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/87R/analysis/html/HC00071S.htm
- Texas Legislature, Senate Concurrent Resolution 50, 87th Legislature (2021) — directing the governor to award the Texas Legislative Medal of Honor posthumously to Marcelino Serna: https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/87R/billtext/html/SC00050F.htm
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members, veterans, and families their own institutions failed.