Peter C. Devereaux: Notified Twenty-Six Years Late, After the Diagnosis
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Peter Devereaux arrived at Camp Lejeune in December 1980, the same year, by his own sworn testimony, that the wells there were discovered to be contaminated. Nobody told him. He drank the water and bathed in it for sixteen months, finished his enlistment, and lived twenty-six more years before the Department of the Navy wrote to tell him that "unregulated chemicals were discovered in some of the base drinking water systems in the early 1980's at Camp Lejeune." By the date on that letter — August 1, 2008 — he had already been diagnosed with an aggressive breast cancer and was already in chemotherapy. This page is the record of his service, his illness, and the letter that came too late.
The service, and the promise
Peter Devereaux was in the Marine Corps from September 1980 to December 1984, and he rose to corporal. His first posting was the one that mattered. In his written testimony to Congress, given on September 16, 2010, he stated it in one sentence: “I was stationed at Camp Lejeune from Dec 1980 – April 1982. I was assigned to the 8th Communication Battalion in the French Creek area of Hadnot Point.”
Hadnot Point is the main side of Marine Corps Base Camp Lejeune, in Jacksonville, North Carolina, and its water system is the one the federal health agencies would later reconstruct as contaminated primarily with trichloroethylene (TCE), along with tetrachloroethylene (PCE), benzene, and vinyl chloride, from leaking storage tanks, industrial spills, and waste sites. None of that was known to the young corporal drinking from it. What he knew was the promise in the Corps’ motto: Semper Fidelis, always faithful — a Marine drinks the water his base provides on the understanding that the institution is watching it on his behalf.
By his own account, he was healthy his whole life before the diagnosis: “Prior to my diagnosis I was in perfect health; always active between work and working out, I ate well, never smoked and hardly drank.” He settled in North Andover, Massachusetts, with his wife — Fiona Maguire, his wife of eighteen years at his death — and their daughter Jackie, who was twelve in 2010. The part of the promise that failed him was about information: what the institution learned about that water, and when it chose to tell him.
What happened
Begin with what Devereaux himself told Congress, because he put the chronology in his own words and the committee printed them:
“The wells were discovered to be contaminated in 1980 when I arrived, the Marines knew about it and said nothing, knowing full well we were bathing in and drinking contaminated water on a daily basis. The water reports all state that the wells were contaminated and action needed to be taken and nothing was done.”
He added a second date: “In March of 1982 a switch to Grainger Analytical Laboratories once again showed contamination and still nothing was done” — one month before he left Camp Lejeune. A warning predated even his arrival: in 1974, he testified, the base commander had declared organic solvents a hazardous substance under Base Order 5100.13B and warned that improper disposal could contaminate the drinking water. The warning existed before he enlisted; the contamination was found the year he arrived; the retest found it again weeks before he left. He was told none of it, then or in the twenty-six years that followed.
In January 2008 — this page carves no specific January day, because his testimony and his obituary coverage give different ones — Devereaux was diagnosed with invasive ductal carcinoma, “a very aggressive form” of breast cancer: stage 3B male breast cancer, a cancer almost unheard of in men, found late, in a man of forty-five. On January 28, 2008, he underwent mastectomy surgery removing his left breast along with 22 cancerous lymph nodes. The following month he began a fourteen-month regimen of 29 chemotherapy and 30 radiation treatments, with daily medication.
After the Navy’s letter arrived, he underwent genetic testing for the breast cancer genes BRCA1 and BRCA2. “I tested negative for both,” he told Congress. “It was then that I really understood my cancer came from my chemical exposure due to the chemicals in the drinking water at Camp Lejeune.” That sentence is recorded here as what it is: his own conclusion, reached after the genetic alternative was excluded. The institutional record is more guarded, and this page keeps the two distinct: the Navy’s position, as reported while he fought his claim, was that more research was needed to connect Lejeune ailments to the contamination, and there was then no presumption in VA law that a Lejeune veteran’s disease was caused by the water.
The treatment was scheduled to end on April 8, 2009. It did not end. “When it was discovered my cancer had spread to my spine, ribs and hip,” he testified, “it is now classified metastatic breast cancer, THERE IS NO CURE!” — the capitals are his, in the printed hearing record. By his testimony he had received 18 more chemotherapy treatments, for a total of 47, and 23 more radiation treatments, for a total of 53. “I will be in treatment until I die,” he said. He could no longer work, and he gave the committee the sentence that explains why a dying man spent a day in a hearing room, about Jackie: “I have no idea if I will see my daughter graduate high school, go to college or get married.”
He did not see those things. Peter C. Devereaux died on August 21, 2014, at 52 — six years after his diagnosis. His Boston Globe obituary records a Marine, boxer, male breast cancer awareness advocate, and long-distance runner who “passed away surrounded by his dedicated family,” survived by Fiona Maguire and Jackie — twelve when he testified, sixteen when he died. His funeral Mass was celebrated on August 25, 2014, in North Andover.
What the institution did afterward
The institution’s first act in his case was the letter, and the letter’s date is the indictment this page is built on. On August 1, 2008, the Department of the Navy informed him that “unregulated chemicals were discovered in some of the base drinking water systems in the early 1980’s at Camp Lejeune,” naming the Hadnot Point system — his system — as one of them. The sequence the documents establish: contamination discovered in 1980, the year he arrived; a confirming test in March 1982, weeks before he left; a stage 3B diagnosis in January 2008; notification on August 1, 2008, twenty-six years after his exposure ended and only after the disease had been found, staged, and operated on. Notification, when it finally came, could no longer protect him from anything. It could only tell him what he had already lost.
The letter asked him to join the USMC Water Registry, and he did. What the registry led to was not an institution reaching for him, but another patient: Mike Partain, himself a Lejeune-born male breast cancer survivor, contacted him and told him he “was the 7th man that was diagnosed with Male Breast Cancer” among the Lejeune cohort. “There are currently 64 men!” Devereaux testified in 2010.
He filed on November 11, 2008. The VA denied the claim in April 2009 — the same month his cancer was found to have metastasized to his spine, ribs, and hip. He appealed, and in May 2010 he received a hearing in Boston. His account of it is the whole case in miniature: “I had 1 hour to present new information about my case with my doctors letters, and letters from Dr Clapp and Senator Kerry of Massachusetts.” One hour, for a terminally ill corporal, to carry a burden of proof set at individual causation — armed with his doctors’ letters, an epidemiologist’s support, and the intervention of his senator, John Kerry.
In August 2010 the appeal succeeded: “My case was approved with 100% disability in August 2010.” The grant mattered — it was how a man who could no longer work could still provide for Fiona and Jackie. But it came twenty-one months after filing, and only after he presented his own evidence in person, with a senator’s help. Presumptive disability coverage for Lejeune veterans did not arrive as a VA rule until 2017, three years after his death, and male breast cancer was not among its eight conditions.
Weeks after the grant, on September 16, 2010, he testified at the hearing titled “Camp Lejeune: Contamination and Compensation, Looking Back, Moving Forward,” and closed with a hope addressed to the institution itself: “I hope the VA will continue to help veterans and civilians affected by the contamination.” What the institution never provided in his lifetime was a route to damages: the Camp Lejeune Justice Act was signed on August 10, 2022, eight years after his death. In his lifetime, its full list of responses to Peter Devereaux was a paper warning in 1974 that preceded him, silence in 1980 and 1982 while he drank, a letter in 2008 after his diagnosis, a denial in 2009 while his cancer spread, and a grant in 2010 that he had to win in person.
Where it stands now
The record in the sources for this page ends with his death and the tributes that followed, and this page will not pretend otherwise. In those sources, his post-2010 story is an advocate’s: he appeared in Semper Fi: Always Faithful, the documentary about the Lejeune contamination, and spoke for male and metastatic breast cancer organizations across the country. He was a featured speaker at the June 2014 Avon Walk for Breast Cancer in Boston, in a wheelchair, two months before his death.
The laws moved on the timetable the other pages on this wall record: health care for Lejeune veterans and families, breast cancer among the covered conditions, under the Janey Ensminger Act of 2012; presumptive benefits for eight conditions — not including breast cancer — under the VA rule finalized in 2017; a damages route under the Camp Lejeune Justice Act of 2022. Whether his family has pursued a claim under the Justice Act is not in these sources, and this page makes no claim about it either way. What remains is the sequence he laid out for Congress, in dates no one has disputed: a hazard declared in 1974, contamination discovered in 1980, a confirming test in March 1982, a Marine told in August 2008, a claim denied in April 2009, a rating won in August 2010, a daughter twelve at the hearing and sixteen at the funeral. He is on this wall because the institution that knew in 1980 reached him in 2008 — and because, reached too late to be warned, he spent the six years left to him making sure the record existed anyway.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- August 1, 2008: The Department of the Navy notified Devereaux that unregulated chemicals had been discovered in some Camp Lejeune drinking water systems in the early 1980s, naming the Hadnot Point system serving the French Creek area where he had been stationed.
- August 2010: After an appeal and a May 2010 hearing in Boston, the VA approved his claim at 100 percent disability — granted on his individual evidence: his doctors’ letters, Dr. Clapp’s letter, and Sen. John Kerry’s intervention.
- September 16, 2010: Devereaux testified before the House Committee on Science and Technology’s Subcommittee on Investigations and Oversight, placing the 1980 discovery, the March 1982 retest, the 2008 letter, the 2009 denial, and the 2010 grant into the congressional record in his own words.
What has not been done
- Notification did not reach him for more than twenty-six years after his exposure — and when it came, on August 1, 2008, it came after his January 2008 stage 3B diagnosis and mastectomy. The warning could no longer warn.
- The VA’s first answer to his November 11, 2008 claim was a denial in April 2009, the same month his cancer was found to have spread to his spine, ribs, and hip.
- No damages route existed in his lifetime. The Camp Lejeune Justice Act was not signed until August 10, 2022, eight years after his death; the 2017 VA presumptive rule, also after his death, did not list male breast cancer among its eight conditions.
What is being sought
- In Devereaux’s own closing words to Congress, that the institution continue what his appeal forced in his single case: “I hope the VA will continue to help veterans and civilians affected by the contamination.”
- That the record he made — the dates, the letter, the denial, the one-hour hearing — stand as the measure of what individual proof cost a terminally ill veteran in the years before any presumption or damages statute existed.
Sources
- Testimony of Peter Devereaux, House Committee on Science and Technology, Subcommittee on Investigations and Oversight, hearing “Camp Lejeune: Contamination and Compensation, Looking Back, Moving Forward,” September 16, 2010 — the primary account, in his own words: the posting; the diagnosis (he gives January 8); the mastectomy, metastasis, and August 1, 2008 letter; the 1980 discovery and March 1982 retest; the November 11, 2008 claim, April 2009 denial, May 2010 hearing, and August 2010 grant (the hearing record elsewhere spells his name “Devereux”; his testimony is signed Devereaux, as is his obituary): http://science.house.gov/sites/republicans.science.house.gov/files/documents/hearings/091610_Devereaux.pdf
- Obituary of Peter C. Devereaux, Boston Globe, August 22–23, 2014, via Legacy.com — age 52; survived by his wife Fiona Maguire and daughter Jackie; funeral Mass August 25, 2014, North Andover: https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/bostonglobe/name/peter-devereaux-obituary?id=10242462
- Metastatic Breast Cancer Network, “Saluting Peter Devereaux, Male Breast Cancer Advocate (1962–2014),” August 2014 — his death at 52; the diagnosis date carried as January 11, 2008 (the variance with his testimony’s January 8 is why this page gives no January day); his wife of 18 years, Fiona Maguire: https://mbcn.org/2014/08/saluting-peter-devereaux-male-breast-cancer-advocate-1962-2014/
- Medivizor, “‘The First Time I Knew I Had Breasts’ — Male Breast Cancer Advocate Passes,” August 25, 2014 — his death on August 21, 2014, leaving a wife and a 16-year-old daughter: http://medivizor.com/blog/2014/08/25/first-time-knew-breasts-male-breast-cancer/
- Massachusetts Breast Cancer Coalition, “Marine Breast Cancer Victim Speaks for Prevention” — seventh Marine diagnosed; by 2013, 83 confirmed cases of breast cancer among Lejeune Marines, described as the largest male cluster ever reported: https://mbcc.org/one-of-83-camp-lejeune-marine-breast-cancer-victims-speak-for-prevention/
- McClatchy Newspapers, “VA Quietly Giving Benefits to Marines Exposed to Toxic Water,” June 2010, via Salem-News — Devereaux, 48, and his daughter Jackie; the Navy’s “more research needed” position; no presumption of causation: http://www.Salem-News.com/articles/june212010/mclatchy-lejeune.php
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.