Peter Pruent: Dead Twenty-Five Years Before the VA Conceded His Death Was Service-Connected
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Peter Pruent's war lasted twelve months, from November 1967 to November 1968, and it included the Tet Offensive. His widow's war lasted from 1990 to 2019 — twenty-nine years of applications, denials, appeals, and courtrooms, fought to establish two things: that the heart disease that killed her husband at forty-one came from his service, and that she was still his widow. The VA took until February 12, 2014 — nearly twenty-five years after his death — to concede the first. New Jersey's courts then took the second away from her, holding that the remarriage she had entered, in poverty, in 1993, extinguished her widowhood in law. Every fact on this page comes from the court opinions that decided her case, which recite the chronology in full. This is the documented record.
The service, and the promise
Peter J. Pruent enlisted in the United States Army in 1967, on graduating from high school. He was trained as a combat soldier and sharpshooter, and he served in Vietnam from November 15, 1967, to November 14, 1968 — a tour that ran through the Tet Offensive of early 1968, the heaviest fighting of the war. He was honorably discharged with the rank of sergeant, a decorated veteran holding the National Defense Service Medal, the Vietnam Service Medal, and the Vietnam Campaign Medal; VA records give his Army service as June 14, 1967 to February 17, 1971.
In 1973 he married Rosanna — he was twenty-five, she was seventeen. He found work as an electrical contractor. Their first daughter was born in 1980 and their second in 1983. The promise made to a man like Peter Pruent had two halves: care for the service-connected disabled veteran, and — should his service kill him — Dependency and Indemnity Compensation for the family he left. Both halves of that promise are the subject of this page, because both had to be fought for, and the second fight was his widow’s, not his.
What happened
In 1983, after the birth of his second daughter, Sgt. Pruent’s health “slowly and progressively began to deteriorate,” as the Tax Court later found. On August 31, 1989, he died, at the age of 41. The cause of death was ventricular arrhythmias and cardiomyopathy — a failure of the heart.
At the time of his death, a national argument about Agent Orange and veterans’ health had been running for nearly two decades, but the United States had not yet acknowledged a causal connection between herbicide exposure in Vietnam and the heart conditions that kill this way. Ischemic heart disease would not be recognized as associated with Agent Orange exposure until a VA regulation took effect on October 30, 2010 — twenty-one years after Peter Pruent’s heart stopped.
What his death left behind, the Tax Court recorded without adornment: “Upon the death of her husband, Plaintiff became an unemployed widow with two small children, and no benefits from the United States Veterans Administration. Without a career, health insurance, or financial stability, the Plaintiff found herself in dire straits.”
What the institution did afterward
The VA fight (1990–2014). Beginning in 1990, Rosanna Pruent filed the first of many applications for Dependency and Indemnity Compensation. She also joined the class action against the manufacturers of Agent Orange; from that settlement, the fund created by Paul Reutershan’s lawsuit, she received $2,000, in 1996.
Concerned about health insurance and financial stability for herself and her daughters, she married Charles J. Stevens in 1993. He was twenty-three years her elder, and also a veteran. He died in 1997, after four years of marriage. Through all of it, she continued to apply to the VA — for DIC, and eventually for Chapter 35 educational assistance for her daughters.
On February 12, 2014 — “almost 25 years after his death,” in the Tax Court’s words — the VA finally determined that Sgt. Pruent’s premature death was “presumptively connected” to his military service in Vietnam. Its reasoning, quoted in the opinion: his Vietnam service was of record, “therefore, exposure to herbicides used in Vietnam is conceded”; and cardiomyopathy was by then a condition recognized under the authority of the Agent Orange Act of 1991. Even the effective date had to be appealed: the VA first made her benefits retroactive only to January 16, 2013 — one year before her last application. She filed a Notice of Disagreement, and the VA amended the retroactive date to August 31, 1989, the day her husband died, approving DIC back to that date, her daughters’ educational benefits, and her own health care and commissary privileges. In its decision, the VA styled her “the un-remarried surviving spouse of Peter J. Pruent” — with full knowledge, documented in the same decision, of her 1993 marriage and of Charles Stevens’s death in 1997. Under federal law, a remarriage that has ended by death is not a permanent bar to DIC. The federal government, knowing everything, paid her as Peter Pruent’s widow, back to 1989.
The township fight (2015–2019). The VA’s determination made Sgt. Pruent, posthumously, a 100 percent disabled veteran for purposes of New Jersey’s property tax exemption for disabled veterans and their surviving spouses (N.J.S.A. 54:4-3.30). On July 30, 2015, Rosanna applied to Toms River Township for the exemption on her home. On August 4, 2015, the municipal tax assessor disallowed the claim, reading the statute to terminate a surviving spouse’s exemption if she has at any time remarried. The Ocean County Board of Taxation upheld the disallowance on May 27, 2016.
She sued. In the Tax Court of New Jersey, she won: on October 2, 2017, Judge Brennan held that “widow” defines a person, not a continuing marital status, and that she met the statute’s requirements for the 2016 tax year. The township appealed. On April 1, 2019, the Appellate Division reversed. Her right to the exemption, the court held, “continued only during her widowhood correlated to the qualifying veteran — her first husband — and was extinguished, per the terms of the statute, when she remarried after the death of that veteran.” The implementing regulation says it in one line: remarriage of the surviving spouse terminates the tax exemption.
So the documented position of the two governments is this, and it does not reconcile: the United States, knowing of the remarriage, restored her DIC to the day of her husband’s death and called her his surviving spouse; the Township of Toms River, upheld by the Appellate Division, held that the same remarriage — undertaken in 1993, when she had two small children, no job, and no insurance, and ended by her second husband’s death in 1997 — erased her widowhood for the one benefit her town controlled.
Where it stands now
The VA’s 2014 determination stands: Peter Pruent’s death is service-connected, his widow’s DIC runs from August 31, 1989, and his daughters’ educational benefits were approved. The Appellate Division’s April 1, 2019 decision also stands, and is a published precedent: in New Jersey, a surviving spouse’s disabled-veteran property tax exemption ends at remarriage, whatever the VA says, and however the remarriage ended.
Rosanna Pruent-Stevens filed her first application in 1990, when her husband had been dead a matter of months and the VA recognized nothing. She was still in court over his service twenty-nine years later. The recognition of what killed him arrived a quarter-century late; the exemption was taken back on a definition. That is the whole of this record, and it is enough.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- On February 12, 2014, the VA determined that Sgt. Pruent’s death was service-connected — herbicide exposure conceded, cardiomyopathy recognized under the Agent Orange Act framework — nearly twenty-five years after he died.
- After her Notice of Disagreement, the VA backdated DIC to August 31, 1989, the date of his death, and approved his daughters’ Chapter 35 educational benefits and her health care benefits.
- The New Jersey Tax Court ruled for her on October 2, 2017, holding that widowhood is a status of person, not a continuing condition of non-remarriage.
What has not been done
- For the first twenty-four years of her widowhood — with two small children, no career, and no insurance — she received no DIC at all; the only compensation in those years was $2,000 from the manufacturers’ settlement fund, in 1996.
- The property tax exemption the VA’s determination qualified her for was denied by Toms River Township, and the denial was upheld by the Appellate Division on April 1, 2019: her 1993 remarriage, ended by death in 1997, extinguished it.
- Ischemic heart disease was not recognized as Agent Orange-associated until October 30, 2010 — twenty-one years after the heart condition on his death certificate killed him at 41.
What is being sought
- The federal account is closed: his death is conceded to be service-connected, paid from the day he died. What remains open is the principle the New Jersey courts settled against her — that a widow who remarried to survive, and was widowed again, is a widow no longer. Her case is now the precedent that says so, until a legislature or a higher court says otherwise.
Sources
- Rosanna Pruent-Stevens v. Township of Toms River, Tax Court of New Jersey, Docket No. 010172-2016 (decided October 2, 2017), reported at 30 N.J. Tax 200 — the court-found chronology: his enlistment, sharpshooter training, Vietnam service of November 15, 1967 – November 14, 1968 and the Tet Offensive, his decorations, the 1973 marriage, the health decline from 1983, his death on August 31, 1989 of ventricular arrhythmias and cardiomyopathy, her DIC applications from 1990, the $2,000 class-action payment in 1996, the 1993 remarriage and Charles Stevens’s 1997 death, the VA’s February 12, 2014 determination, the retroactivity fight from January 16, 2013 back to August 31, 1989, the October 30, 2010 ischemic-heart-disease regulation, and the township’s August 4, 2015 disallowance: https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/tax-court/2017/10172-2016.html
- Rosanna Pruent-Stevens v. Toms River Township, Superior Court of New Jersey, Appellate Division, Docket No. A-1264-17T2 (decided April 1, 2019) — reversing the Tax Court: the exemption “continued only during her widowhood correlated to the qualifying veteran” and “was extinguished… when she remarried,” under N.J.S.A. 54:4-3.30(b)(2) and N.J.A.C. 18:28-2.5(b): https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/appellate-division-published/2019/a1264-17.html
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.