Richard Miles: The Veteran Who Asked for Help, and Was Sent Home
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Richard Miles did the thing the system tells a veteran in crisis to do. On February 15, 2015, he walked into the Department of Veterans Affairs hospital in Des Moines, Iowa, and told the staff, in the words recorded in his own hospital records: "I need help." He had told his friends he was going to check himself in. He was diagnosed with worsened PTSD, given medication, and sent home. Five days later, on February 20, 2015, a man walking his dog found his body in the woods of Water Works Park. This page is that week's documented record — the records, the VA's answers, the inspector general's conclusion, and the family's reply.
The service, and the promise
Richard Miles joined the Army in 2002 and served through 2006, according to the statement released by his friends after his death. He was based out of Fort Riley, Kansas, and served as a sergeant, a squad leader, and a protocol manager. He deployed to Iraq three times. He was 40 years old when he died, and he was a father.
The record of what the war left with him is in his own medical file, as reported by CNN from the more than 1,200 pages of records his family released. Medical records obtained by CNN state that after Miles returned from Iraq in 2004, he “began to experience depression with suicidal attempts.” Katie Hopper, his friend and the mother of his daughter, recalled for CNN one memory that stayed with him: an interrogation incident with a frail, old Iraqi man, which upset him a great deal. His diagnosis was post-traumatic stress disorder, and it was not new or undocumented by 2015. He had been hospitalized at the Iowa VA hospital four times for PTSD between 2008 and 2009, after he “made 2 attempts to hang himself,” according to his records. That history was in the file of the same health care system he walked into on February 15, 2015.
At home in Des Moines, he had built a working life on the other side of that record. Miles was one of the premiere presenters at the Science Center of Iowa, a beloved employee popular with the staff and the guests.
The promise made to a veteran like Richard Miles is not complicated: the system that documented his injury will be there when the injury worsens. He had used that system before — four hospitalizations in two years — and it had held him. The question this page accounts for is what it did the last time he came to its door and said the words himself.
What happened
In the days before his last visit, Miles had disappeared from his job for several days. On February 15, 2015, he left several of his belongings with Katie Hopper and went to the VA hospital in Des Moines. He had told Hopper and another friend, Harry Aller, that he was going to check himself in at the VA. In the words of the hospital records obtained by CNN, he told the staff: “I need help.”
What the emergency department did with that request is not in dispute; the dispute is over whether it was enough. Miles was diagnosed with “worsened PTSD,” anxiety, and insomnia. He was not admitted. He was given anxiety and insomnia medication on his departure and sent home, with an outpatient psychotherapy appointment scheduled for seven days from that point. The VA would later state that the medication was one Miles indicated had helped him in the past.
He disappeared two days later. Records show friends called the VA to look for him and later filed a missing person report with local law enforcement. A few days after the visit, after giving his daughter Emmalynn a big hug goodbye, he walked into the woods — woods where he and Hopper used to go — and did not come back.
On Friday, February 20, 2015, at 3:36 p.m., a man walking his dog called police to report a body found in the woods of Water Works Park in Des Moines. That body was Richard Miles. He was found with no jacket and no shoes. The toxicology report obtained by CNN showed he had ingested a toxic but not fatal amount of lorazepam — the sleeping medication prescribed just a few days before, at the VA visit of February 15. He died from exposure to the elements: he froze to death in a public park in his own city, five days after presenting himself to the institution charged with his care and asking, on the record, for help.
His family then did the thing that made this case a public record rather than a private file: they released his records — more than 1,200 pages — to CNN, which provided them to Dr. Elspeth Cameron Ritchie, a longtime Army psychiatrist, for independent review. Hopper’s verdict on the VA’s part in his death was stated plainly: “The VA failed him. They failed him.”
What the institution did afterward
The Department of Veterans Affairs answered first with a statement. Emergency room staff “followed proper mental health screening procedures and then scheduled an outpatient psychotherapy appointment for seven days from that point,” the Department of Veterans Affairs said in a statement to CNN, adding that Miles was “given anxiety and insomnia medication upon his departure from the emergency room — medication he indicated had helped him in the past.”
That was the institution’s first accounting: procedure followed, appointment made, medication given — delivered while the facts standing against it were already in the public record the family had released: the four prior hospitalizations, the two prior hanging attempts, the worsened-PTSD diagnosis entered that day, and the words “I need help” in his own chart.
The second accounting was demanded from outside the VA. On February 23, 2015 — three days after Miles’s body was found — U.S. Senator Joni Ernst of Iowa wrote to the Inspector General of the Department of Veterans Affairs. “It is tragic our nation lost a veteran who may not have received the mental health treatment he deserved,” Ernst wrote. “I request your office conduct an immediate and thorough investigation into the VA Central Iowa Health Care System mental health care programs, treatment provided to veteran Richard Miles, and Mr. Miles’ requests for mental health care and the subsequent treatment received.”
The VA Office of Inspector General initiated a review and told Ernst’s office it would share its findings in approximately one month. That month passed. In a Senate hearing in June 2015, Ernst put the delay on the record: “the Office of the VA IG has told me on multiple occasions that they would get the report to me. Again, I requested this report in February, it is now June… so it is very frustrating and absolutely unacceptable that it has taken so long.” They had told her April, she said. Then May. She had still received no answer.
When the inspector general’s report came, in June 2015, it cleared the VA. Its central finding, in its own words: “We did not substantiate the allegation that the patient had been denied long term mental health services at the time of a winter 2015 Emergency Department visit. We found no documentation that the patient had requested these services or that his clinical condition would have warranted admission at the time of his presentation.” CNN noted what the report did not contain: that Miles said “I need help” when he came to the emergency room is not mentioned in the report. On the seven-day wait for his outpatient appointment — an appointment he did not live to keep — the report stated that “the facility appeared to be substantially in compliance with its policy regarding time frames for consult completion,” which is 14 days.
The report did make two suggestions. Miles, who had post-traumatic stress and had attempted suicide, was not considered to have had a “serious mental illness,” such as schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. The IG suggested that the Interim Under Secretary for Health “determine the feasibility and advisability of expanding recovery coordination activities to patients with post-traumatic stress disorder.” It also recommended that the VA make sure the VA Central Iowa Health Care System director “provides all levels of Operation Enduring Freedom/Operation Iraqi Freedom case management services in accordance with Veterans Health Administration policy.”
The family’s answer to the report was one word. “I would definitely use the term whitewash,” Katie Hopper said of the report, speaking to CNN on behalf of the family that had released 1,200 pages of records so the case could be judged on documents rather than statements.
Where it stands now
On the documented record, the case closed the way it opened: with the institution’s procedures affirmed by the institution’s own watchdog, and the family rejecting that affirmation on the record.
The VA’s position remains the one it took in March 2015 — that its staff followed proper screening procedures — now joined by the inspector general’s June 2015 finding that denied care was not substantiated and that his condition would not have warranted admission. Against that stands the file the family put into public view: a veteran with two prior hanging attempts and four PTSD hospitalizations in his record, a worsened-PTSD diagnosis on February 15, 2015, a request for help in his own words that the inspector general’s report does not mention, a discharge with medication and a seven-day wait, and a body found in Water Works Park five days later, dead of exposure after taking a toxic amount of the medication prescribed at that visit.
The remembrance, at least, continued on the record. On March 23, 2016, an event at the Vietnam War Memorial at the Iowa State Capitol marked the first Veterans Black Arm Band Day for PTSD in remembrance of Miles. Iowa State Senator Mark Segebart read from the event’s program on the Senate floor: “Nothing has changed since PTSD combat veteran Richard Miles was laid to rest on March 23 — one year ago today. He froze to death in a public park as his PTSD terror worsened.”
Nothing in the sources for this page records an admission of fault by the VA in Richard Miles’s care, a reversal of the inspector general’s finding, or a change to the classification that treated a suicidal veteran’s PTSD as something short of a serious mental illness. What the record holds is two accounts that do not reconcile — the institution’s, in which procedure was followed, and his family’s, in the words his daughter’s mother has repeated on the record: the VA failed him; they failed him. This page keeps both accounts where they belong: in the open, on the documents.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- The family released Richard Miles’s complete records — more than 1,200 pages — to CNN, which reported the case nationally on March 19, 2015, and provided the records to Dr. Elspeth Cameron Ritchie for independent review. The case is public because the family made it public.
- Senator Joni Ernst demanded a federal investigation on February 23, 2015, for “an immediate and thorough investigation” into the VA Central Iowa Health Care System’s mental health programs and Miles’s treatment — and pressed the IG publicly in June 2015 when the report was months overdue.
- The VA Office of Inspector General issued its report in June 2015, with two recommendations: that the VA determine the feasibility of expanding recovery coordination to patients with PTSD, and that it ensure the Central Iowa system provides all levels of Operation Enduring Freedom/Operation Iraqi Freedom case management in accordance with Veterans Health Administration policy.
- Miles has been remembered on the record in Iowa: the first Veterans Black Arm Band Day for PTSD was held in his remembrance on March 23, 2016, at the Iowa State Capitol.
What has not been done
- The inspector general did not substantiate any failure in Miles’s care. It found no documentation that he had requested long-term services or that his condition warranted admission — and its report does not mention that he told the emergency room staff, “I need help.” No VA finding of fault in his February 15, 2015 visit appears in the record.
- The medication question was never answered by the institution: Miles died of exposure after ingesting a toxic amount of lorazepam prescribed at the visit that sent him home, and the VA’s public account of that visit describes the medication only as one he said had helped him in the past.
- The classification gap the IG itself identified was left as a suggestion: a veteran with PTSD and prior suicide attempts was not considered to have a “serious mental illness,” and the IG’s remedy was to ask the VA to determine whether expanding recovery coordination to PTSD patients would be feasible and advisable.
- The appointment the VA scheduled for him — outpatient psychotherapy seven days out — was never kept. He was dead in five.
What is being sought
- The investigation Senator Ernst demanded on February 23, 2015, in its full terms: an accounting not only of one emergency-room visit, but of the VA Central Iowa Health Care System’s mental health care programs and of how a veteran with Miles’s documented history could ask for help in person and be sent home.
- The standard his family stated when they released his records and when they answered the IG report: that the VA’s failure be named as they named it. “The VA failed him. They failed him,” Katie Hopper said. “I would definitely use the term whitewash,” she said of the report that cleared it.
- That the next veteran who walks into an emergency department and says “I need help” — with a file like Richard Miles’s behind him — is admitted and treated as the emergency he says he is, rather than scheduled a week out and sent home.
Sources
- CNN, via GantNews, “Troubled Iowa veteran sought help from VA hospital before freezing to death,” March 19, 2015 — the CNN investigation from Miles’s 1,200+ pages of records: https://gantnews.com/2015/03/19/troubled-iowa-veteran-sought-help-from-va-hospital-before-freezing-to-death/
- CNN, via GantNews, “Veteran’s family calls report exonerating VA a ‘Whitewash’,” June 11, 2015 — the IG finding, the omission of “I need help,” and Hopper’s “whitewash” response: https://gantnews.com/2015/06/11/veterans-family-calls-report-exonerating-va-a-whitewash/
- Bleeding Heartland, “Mid-week open thread: Tragedies,” February 26, 2015 — the friends’ timeline and statement: https://www.bleedingheartland.com/2015/02/26/mid-week-open-thread-tragedies/
- U.S. Senator Joni Ernst, “Senator Ernst Receives Update on Request for Examination of the VA Central Iowa Health Care System’s Mental Health Programs” — the February 23, 2015 letter to the VA Inspector General: https://www.ernst.senate.gov/news/press-releases/senator-ernst-receives-update-on-request-for-examination-of-the-va-central-iowa-health-care-systems-mental-health-programs
- U.S. Senator Joni Ernst, “Sen. Ernst Calls Attention to Vacant VA IG Position, Failure to Provide an Update on Central Iowa’s VA Health Care” — Ernst’s June 2015 hearing remarks: https://www.ernst.senate.gov/news/press-releases/sen-ernst-calls-attention-to-vacant-va-ig-position-failure-to-provide-an-update-on-central-iowas-va-health-care
- KJAN, “Event tries to draw attention to veterans suffering from PTSD,” March 24, 2016 — the first Veterans Black Arm Band Day for PTSD in Miles’s remembrance: https://www.kjan.com/index.php/page/10437/?cat=jvkollwhemotic
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.