Roy P. Benavidez: Wounded Thirty-Seven Times, Then Made to Prove It Twice
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Roy P. Benavidez was put in a body bag on May 2, 1968, and had to spit in a doctor's face to prove he was still alive. He had jumped into a fight against a battalion-sized enemy force to rescue a surrounded twelve-man team, and over six hours he took 37 separate bullet, bayonet, and shrapnel wounds and saved at least eight men. The Army's own record of that day was never in dispute. What followed it is the subject of this page: a Medal of Honor that took thirteen years, an eyewitness who had to be found on the other side of the world, and — five years after the medal finally came — a second fight, against a second agency, to keep the disability pay of a man who still carried shrapnel in his heart.
The service, and the promise
Raul Perez “Roy” Benavidez was born on August 5, 1935, at Cuero, Texas. Orphaned as a boy, he dropped out of school and enlisted in the Texas Army National Guard in 1952, then entered the regular Army at Houston in June 1955. He made himself into a Green Beret — a soldier of the 5th Special Forces Group (Airborne) — and served in the orbit of the Military Assistance Command, Vietnam – Studies and Observations Group (MACV-SOG), the command that ran the war’s most secret missions.
Vietnam had already nearly taken him once. In December 1965 he stepped on a mine, was evacuated to San Antonio, and was told he would never walk again. He walked, returned to duty, and went back to Vietnam. By the spring of 1968 he was a staff sergeant assigned to Detachment B-56, 5th Special Forces Group (Airborne), 1st Special Forces, stationed at the forward operating base at Loc Ninh.
The promise the Army makes to a soldier like Benavidez runs in both directions. He is asked to go where he is sent and to do what the mission requires, up to and including his life. In return, the institution undertakes to record what he did accurately, to honor it at the level it deserves, and to care for what the service cost his body. The first of those undertakings is the decorations system: a recommendation, eyewitness accounts, review by the Army Decorations Board, and award by the President in the name of Congress. The second is the disability system, which exists so that a man retired for his wounds is not left to negotiate with his own government for his income. Roy Benavidez’s record tests both promises, in sequence, over fifteen years.
What happened
On the morning of May 2, 1968, a twelve-man Special Forces reconnaissance team was inserted by helicopter into dense jungle west of Loc Ninh to gather intelligence on confirmed large-scale enemy activity. The team was surrounded and pinned down by a battalion-sized North Vietnamese force. Three extraction attempts were driven off by heavy fire.
Benavidez was at the forward operating base, monitoring the operation by radio, when the extraction helicopters returned to offload wounded crewmen and assess their damage. He voluntarily boarded a returning aircraft for another extraction attempt. The Medal of Honor citation — the Army’s own final account of the day — records what he did over the roughly six hours that followed. Carrying a medical bag, he jumped from the hovering helicopter and ran through enemy fire to the trapped team, and was wounded in the leg, face, and head reaching it. He took command of the survivors, administered first aid, dragged wounded men to a defensive perimeter, distributed ammunition, directed air strikes, and called in tactical air support to suppress the enemy enough for an extraction to be attempted. When a helicopter finally landed, he supervised the loading of the wounded under fire that was, in the citation’s words, increasing to a fever pitch. He was clubbed from behind — sustaining additional wounds to his head and arms — while defending a fallen comrade, killed the attacker in hand-to-hand fighting, and then, before boarding, made a final sweep of the area to recover classified documents from the body of the dead team leader and to be certain no wounded man was left behind. He spotted and killed two enemy soldiers rushing the aircraft from an angle its door gunner could not cover, and was wounded again as he boarded. The citation closes the count plainly: his actions saved the lives of at least eight men.
His own body told the rest of the story. Benavidez had sustained 37 separate bullet, bayonet, and shrapnel wounds. Back at Loc Ninh, he was examined, believed dead, and placed in a body bag among the dead. As the doctor was about to zip the bag closed, Benavidez — unable to move or speak — spat in the doctor’s face to show that he was alive. He spent almost a year in hospital recovering.
He did recover, and he stayed in uniform. He retired from the Army in 1976, on total disability, with his wife Hilaria “Lala” Benavidez and their three children settled at El Campo, Texas. The wounds retired with him: pieces of shrapnel remained in his heart, his lung was punctured, and he lived in constant pain from what May 2, 1968 had done to him. The disability pay that came with that retirement was the income the family at El Campo lived on.
What the institution did afterward
The first failure was a failure of valuation, made in a hospital room. Benavidez’s commander believed he deserved the Medal of Honor. He put him in for the Distinguished Service Cross — the Army’s second-highest award for valor — instead, because the Medal of Honor process took a long time and the commander was sure Benavidez would die before it could be completed. Army Chief of Staff Gen. William Westmoreland presented the Distinguished Service Cross to Benavidez at Brooke Army Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, while he was still recovering. The lesser medal was, on the record, a bet that the man would not live long enough to receive the greater one. He lived.
In 1973, his former commander, Lt. Col. Ralph R. Drake, having obtained more detailed accounts of the action, insisted that Benavidez receive the Medal of Honor and began the campaign to upgrade the award. The campaign ran into the statute book. The time limit for the medal had expired, and although Congress extended the window for Southeast Asia decorations — Drake’s recommendation was processed under Public Law 93-469, enacted in October 1974 — the Army Decorations Board denied the upgrade. The board required an eyewitness account from someone present during the action other than Benavidez himself, and Benavidez believed no such witness had survived the six hours west of Loc Ninh.
He was wrong, and the proof was in Fiji. Brian O’Connor, the team’s radioman, had been severely wounded that day — Benavidez believed him dead — and evacuated to the United States before his superiors could fully debrief him. In 1980, living in the Fiji Islands and on holiday in Australia, O’Connor read a newspaper account of Benavidez, reprinted from an El Campo newspaper, contacted him at once, and submitted a ten-page eyewitness report confirming the accounts of the action. Congress completed the legal clearance with Private Law 96-81, enacted December 18, 1980, removing the statutory time limit in Benavidez’s case. President Jimmy Carter approved the upgrade on December 31, 1980. On February 24, 1981, at the Pentagon, President Ronald Reagan presented the Medal of Honor to Master Sergeant Roy P. Benavidez — thirteen years after the morning it was earned. Reagan told the audience that if the story of his heroism were a movie script, they would not believe it.
The second failure came two years later, from a different institution, and it is the one that belongs on this wall beside the first. In 1983, the Social Security Administration, in a cost-cutting review of disability rolls that had terminated assistance to some 350,000 people over the preceding two years, ruled that Roy Benavidez — retired on total disability since 1976, shrapnel still in his heart — was able to work, and moved to cut off the disability payments he had received since his retirement. Benavidez came forward publicly shortly before Memorial Day 1983. He did not frame the fight as his own. “I don’t like to use my Medal of Honor for political purposes or personal gain,” he said, “but if they can do this to me, what will they do to all the others?” Wearing the medal, he testified before the House Select Committee on Aging that, in his words, the administration that put this medal around his neck was curtailing his benefits. The White House said President Reagan was personally concerned; ten days after Benavidez spoke, Secretary of Health and Human Services Margaret Heckler announced the disability reviews would be made more humane and compassionate. Benavidez appealed his own termination to an administrative law judge, who ruled in July 1983 that his payments should continue.
Where it stands now
The medal is on the record, where it has stood since February 24, 1981: the Distinguished Service Cross of 1968 upgraded to the Medal of Honor, the citation’s account of May 2, 1968 unchallenged, the thirteen-year delay a documented part of the same record. The disability payments were restored by the administrative law judge’s ruling in July 1983, and the Texas State Historical Association’s account credits his testimony with contributing to the restoration of benefits to many other recipients caught in the same review — the outcome Benavidez himself had asked for when he framed his case as a test of what would be done to all the others.
Roy Benavidez spent his remaining years speaking to young people and to soldiers, and wrote his own accounts of his wars. He died on November 29, 1998, at Brooke Army Medical Center in San Antonio — the same hospital where he had received the Distinguished Service Cross thirty years before — at the age of sixty-three. What remains open in his record is not a claim but a pattern, and it is the pattern this site exists to document: the institution’s first judgment of his service was made on the assumption he would die before it could be corrected; its correction required an act of Congress, a presidential approval on the last day of a presidency, and a witness found by chance in an Australian newspaper; and when the medal was finally around his neck, another arm of the same government reviewed the file of a man with shrapnel in his heart and pronounced him fit for work. Both times, the record was set right only because Roy Benavidez refused to accept the first answer.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- The Distinguished Service Cross was awarded in 1968 and presented by Gen. William Westmoreland at Brooke Army Medical Center — awarded, on the commander’s own reasoning, because Benavidez was expected to die before a Medal of Honor could be processed.
- The Medal of Honor upgrade was approved by President Carter on December 31, 1980, after Congress removed the statutory time limit (Private Law 96-81, December 18, 1980) and the missing eyewitness, radioman Brian O’Connor, was located in 1980 and submitted his account. President Reagan presented the medal on February 24, 1981.
- The Social Security Administration’s 1983 termination was reversed in Benavidez’s own case: an administrative law judge ruled in July 1983 that his disability payments continue, and the administration publicly committed to more humane and compassionate reviews after his House testimony.
What has not been done
- The Medal of Honor was not awarded when it was earned, or when his commander first sought the upgrade in 1973. It took thirteen years, a private act of Congress, and a witness presumed dead — no part of the system found Brian O’Connor; a newspaper reprint in Australia did.
- No record shows the 1983 disability determination being acknowledged, by the agency that made it, as the error the administrative law judge’s reversal established it to be. A man retired on total disability in 1976, still carrying shrapnel in his heart, was ruled able to work, and the ruling stood until he carried his medal to Capitol Hill and appealed it himself.
What is being sought
- Nothing remains pending for Roy Benavidez himself; he died on November 29, 1998. What is sought is the accounting itself — that the file record both halves of his story together: the six hours west of Loc Ninh, and the fifteen years his own institutions spent deciding what those six hours, and the body they left him, were worth.
Sources
- Congressional Research Service, Medal of Honor: History and Issues, CRS Report 95-519 — the Distinguished Service Cross, the commander’s upgrade recommendation, the denial until the missing eyewitness was located in 1980, President Carter’s approval of the upgrade on December 31, 1980, President Reagan’s presentation on February 24, 1981, and Congress’s enactment of P.L. 96-81 on December 18, 1980 removing the statutory time limit: https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20150818_95-519_05e98203988005106bc44a943f783775a2184326.pdf
- Art Leatherwood, “Benavidez, Raul Perez [Roy],” Handbook of Texas Online, Texas State Historical Association — his birth at Cuero on August 5, 1935, his retirement with total disability in 1976, the 1983 Social Security challenge, his testimony before the U.S. House Select Committee on Aging and its contribution to restoring benefits to many recipients, and his death on November 29, 1998: https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/benavidez-raul-perez-roy
- U.S. Army, “Benavidez set standard for selfless sacrifice” — the commander who put him in for the Distinguished Service Cross because the Medal of Honor process took a long time and he was sure Benavidez would die before receiving it, Westmoreland’s presentation at Brooke Army Medical Center, and the body-bag recovery: https://www.army.mil/article/239466
- Congressional Medal of Honor Society, recipient record for Roy P. Benavidez — Detachment B-56, 5th Special Forces Group (Airborne), the May 2, 1968 action west of Loc Ninh, and the February 24, 1981 presentation by President Reagan at the Pentagon: https://www.cmohs.org/kiosk/recipients/roy-p-benavidez
- Richard Goldstein, obituary of Roy P. Benavidez, New York Times, December 4, 1998 (as reproduced in the Army Special Forces Association record) — the 1983 Social Security termination, the cost-cutting review that had ended assistance to 350,000 people, the shrapnel in his heart and punctured lung, his statement to reporters, his House testimony, and the administrative law judge’s July 1983 ruling restoring his payments: http://www.asalives.org/ASAONLINE/be.htm
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.