The Tongo Tongo Four: Green Berets Sent Into Niger Without the Training, Rehearsals, or Approval Their Mission Required
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Four American soldiers went into the Nigerien border country on October 4, 2017, with a partner force they had not rehearsed with, after a deployment in which their team had never completed its key collective training together, on a mission whose written concept had not accurately described what they were being sent to do. An Islamic State affiliate ambush killed Sgt. 1st Class Jeremiah W. Johnson, Staff Sgt. Bryan C. Black, Staff Sgt. Dustin M. Wright, and Sgt. La David T. Johnson — and four Nigerien soldiers fighting beside them. Seven months later, the Pentagon's own investigation said the deaths grew out of "individual, organizational and institutional failures." This page is that record.
The service, and the promise
The four Americans were Army Special Forces soldiers serving in Niger as part of a small advise-and-assist mission:
- Sgt. 1st Class Jeremiah W. Johnson
- Staff Sgt. Bryan C. Black
- Staff Sgt. Dustin M. Wright
- Sgt. La David T. Johnson
They operated with Nigerien partner forces in a region where the Islamic State in the Greater Sahara and other armed groups moved across porous borders. A team of that kind depends on preparation that cannot be improvised after contact: collective training with the exact soldiers who will deploy, rehearsals and battle drills with the partner force, an accurately written mission concept approved at the level required, intelligence that reflects the threat, and support that can arrive in time.
That is the promise underneath an advise-and-assist mission. The team is small by design. Its safety therefore rests on the institution around it — the command that trains it, writes and approves its mission, understands the ground it will enter, and arranges help before help is needed.
The Pentagon’s investigation later found failures in each of those supports. The team had not completed key pre-deployment collective training as a complete team, in part because personnel turnover kept changing its composition. It had not conducted the pre-mission rehearsals and battle drills with its Nigerien partners that preparation required. And the initial concept of operations — the CONOPS — inaccurately characterized the mission and was not approved at the proper level.
None of that changes who fired the weapons in the ambush. An enemy force did. But the institution’s own investigators refused to stop the accounting at enemy action. They traced the conditions under which the team entered the fight, and they found that the Army and the joint force had sent it in less ready than its mission demanded.
What happened
On October 4, 2017, the American team and its Nigerien partners were operating near the village of Tongo Tongo in southwestern Niger. Their work shifted in the field, and on the return from the mission the combined force was ambushed by a much larger enemy force.
The Pentagon’s investigation concluded that the Americans and Nigeriens were surprised by an enemy with a significant tactical advantage. The fight was not a brief exchange. The team called for support after the ambush began, and the support timeline became part of the institutional record:
- Air support was requested 53 minutes into the engagement.
- French aircraft were overhead about 47 minutes after that request.
- A Nigerien quick-reaction force arrived roughly four and a half hours after the call, having left its base about eight minutes after notification.
Three of the Americans — Sgt. 1st Class Johnson, Staff Sgt. Black, and Staff Sgt. Wright — were killed in the ambush. Sgt. La David Johnson became separated during the fight. His body was recovered near the village two days later.
Four Nigerien partner soldiers were also killed. Their deaths belong in this accounting. The American team did not fight alone, and the partner force whose rehearsals with the Americans had never properly happened absorbed the same ambush.
The enemy inflicted the deaths. The investigation nevertheless asked the harder question: why had a small team been placed in a position where surprise, distance, and delayed support left it so exposed? The answers were not found in the last minutes of the fight. They were found in the months before it — in training rosters changed by turnover, in rehearsals that never occurred, in a mission description that did not match the mission, and in a chain of approval that did not function as the rules required.
What the institution did afterward
The Army and U.S. Africa Command investigated under Army Regulation 15-6. The investigating officer was Maj. Gen. Roger L. Cloutier Jr. Secretary of Defense James Mattis and Africa Command commander Gen. Thomas D. Waldhauser publicly briefed the results on May 10, 2018 — more than seven months after the ambush.
The investigation’s conclusion, as the Pentagon stated it, was that the deaths resulted from a complex set of “individual, organizational and institutional failures and deficiencies.” No single factor within American control, the investigators said, by itself caused the outcome. The enemy achieved surprise and brought a far larger force against the team. But the failures the report documented were concrete:
- The team never completed key pre-deployment collective training as a complete team. Personnel turnover meant the soldiers who deployed had not trained together in the full configuration the mission required.
- The team and its Nigerien partners conducted no pre-mission rehearsals or battle drills together before the operation.
- The initial concept of operations inaccurately characterized the mission and was not approved at the proper level.
- The mission changed in the field in ways the original paperwork had not accurately anticipated or authorized.
- Preparation, intelligence, and planning did not match the threat the team encountered.
Waldhauser summarized the same findings at the Pentagon briefing: there were failures in training, in planning, and in the procedures governing how the mission was described and approved. Secretary Mattis directed changes to doctrine, training, and procedures, with report-backs on implementation due within 120 days.
For the families, the seven months before that briefing were their own part of the record. They waited from October 2017 until May 2018 for the military’s full official account of how their soldiers had died.
Sgt. La David Johnson’s widow, Myeshia Johnson, fought the Army publicly over the notification she received and over what she had been told about her husband’s death. Her dispute was not an argument about the investigation’s training findings. It was about the family’s side of the promise: that when the institution sends a soldier into danger and he does not come back, it will tell the people who loved him the truth, promptly and consistently, and treat them as owed that truth rather than as a problem to be managed. Her public challenge made clear that, in her experience, that promise had not been kept.
The two records stand together. The Pentagon admitted institutional failure in the mission’s preparation. A widow said the institution had also failed her in how it communicated with her afterward. Neither admission was volunteered quickly.
Where it stands now
The May 2018 investigation remains the official account. It established that the ambush was an enemy action and that the enemy held the tactical advantage — and it established, in the same breath, that the team’s readiness had been compromised by failures the institution controlled: incomplete collective training, no rehearsals with the partner force, and a mission concept that was inaccurately written and approved at the wrong level.
What the public record does not contain is a matching ledger of personal accountability. The findings name failures by category — individual, organizational, institutional — and the Pentagon announced reforms to doctrine, training, and procedures. But the investigation’s public summary does not assign the inaccurate CONOPS, the missing rehearsals, or the incomplete training to named officials with named consequences. “Institutional failure” is a finding. It is not the same thing as a person being held responsible.
The families received the official account in May 2018. Sgt. La David Johnson’s family received, in addition, a public dispute with the Army over what his widow had been told — a dispute the Army never resolved to her satisfaction in public.
The four soldiers’ names are now attached to a lesson the institution says it learned about preparing small teams for partner missions. The record that supports the lesson is the Pentagon’s own. It says the team was brave, that the enemy was larger and held the advantage, and that the failures began long before the first shot — in the training that was never completed, the rehearsals that never happened, and the paperwork that did not describe the mission the team was actually sent to perform.
The ledger
What was owed
- A team that had completed its collective pre-deployment training together before it deployed.
- Rehearsals and battle drills with the Nigerien partner force before a joint mission.
- A concept of operations that accurately described the mission, approved at the proper level.
- Support close enough, and fast enough, to matter when a small team met a larger force.
- A prompt, truthful accounting to the four American families and to the families of the four Nigerien partners killed beside them.
What was paid
- Four American lives on October 4, 2017: Sgt. 1st Class Jeremiah W. Johnson, Staff Sgt. Bryan C. Black, Staff Sgt. Dustin M. Wright, and Sgt. La David T. Johnson — and four Nigerien partner soldiers killed in the same ambush.
- A support timeline measured in the investigation itself: air support requested 53 minutes into the fight; French aircraft overhead about 47 minutes later; a Nigerien quick-reaction force on scene roughly four and a half hours after notification.
- Seven months between the ambush and the Pentagon’s public accounting on May 10, 2018.
- An official finding of “individual, organizational and institutional failures and deficiencies” — including incomplete collective training, no partner rehearsals or battle drills, and a CONOPS that inaccurately characterized the mission and was not approved at the proper level.
- Directed changes to doctrine, training, and procedures, with implementation report-backs ordered within 120 days of the May 2018 briefing.
What remains open
- The public investigation summary assigns the failures to categories, not to named officials with named consequences. Who wrote the inaccurate CONOPS, who approved it at the wrong level, and what happened to them is not answered in the cited record.
- Myeshia Johnson’s public dispute with the Army over her notification and what she was told stands unresolved in the public record.
- The four Nigerien soldiers killed in the ambush are counted in the official accounting; the cited U.S. record does not name them or record what their families were told.