Wesley Black: The VA Treated His Cancer as Irritable Bowel for Four Years
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
This case is not about a denied claim. Wesley Black was one of the rare Vermont burn-pit veterans the VA did service-connect. This case is about what happened inside a VA hospital: a young combat veteran walked into the White River Junction VA for roughly four years with documented burn-pit exposure, a 75-pound weight loss, and severe intestinal symptoms, and walked out each time with a diagnosis of irritable bowel syndrome. Nobody looked for cancer. When an emergency room finally did, the cancer was stage IV. His lawsuit said the delay converted a curable cancer into a terminal one, and the government settled it for $3 million weeks before he died. This page is the documented record.
The service, and the promise
Wesley “Wes” Black enlisted in the Vermont Army National Guard in November 2003, a Norwich University student, and deployed twice: to Ramadi, Iraq, in 2005–2006, and to Afghanistan in 2009–2010. He earned the Combat Infantryman Badge and a Bronze Star with Valor. He was medically retired in 2015. On both deployments he lived and worked around burn pits — the open-air incineration the military used for its waste stream. In his own description, repeated in his lawsuit and his testimony, he frequently breathed smoke from pits burning human and medical waste, plastic water bottles, ammunition, and chemicals. He came home to Hartford, Vermont, became a firefighter, married Laura, and had a son, Ronan.
The promise in Black’s case was the most basic one a health system makes: when a veteran with a documented toxic exposure arrives with symptoms, the system will consider what the exposure can do. Burn pits were not an unknown quantity by the time Black was presenting at White River Junction. The VA maintained a burn pit registry he joined; veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan had been raising the exposure for years; Black himself became one of the Vermonters pressing the state on it. The file the VA held on Wes Black contained both halves of the equation — the exposure and, as the years passed, the symptoms. What the record shows is that inside his own VA, the two halves were never put together.
What happened
Over roughly four years, Black was treated at the White River Junction VA Medical Center for collapsing health: he lost 75 pounds and suffered severe intestinal symptoms. The diagnosis the VA settled on was irritable bowel syndrome. The lawsuit he later filed alleged what the Associated Press reported plainly: doctors incorrectly diagnosed him with irritable bowel syndrome, and the VA never worked him up for the cancer that was producing the symptoms — despite the exposure history sitting in his record. His attorney’s summary of the malpractice claim, as reported, was that the VA did not consider Black’s wartime exposure to burn pits in the diagnosis at all.
The cancer was found the way cancers in this story are so often found: not by the system that had been watching him, but by an emergency. Black ended up in an emergency room; a colonoscopy revealed stage IV colon cancer. He was in his early thirties.
The malpractice case turned on a before-and-after that medicine can date. A physician at the Gastrointestinal Cancer Center of the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston wrote in a 2018 letter supporting what Black’s suit alleged: that the symptoms the VA had under its care were the early signs of the cancer, that they warranted investigation for it, and that the years of IBS treatment were years in which a curable disease became an incurable one. The suit’s framing — that the delay converted a curable cancer into a terminal one — was thus not a family’s grief speaking. It was the pleaded, expert-supported theory of the case the government ultimately paid to resolve.
Black lived the rest of his life in public, deliberately. Diagnosed terminally, he testified for Vermont’s burn-pit notification law — the law requiring the VA in Vermont to contact every Vermont veteran who served overseas and tell them they may have been exposed — and for the federal PACT Act. He understood his own prognosis and said so, in words Speaker Nancy Pelosi later carried to the House floor: “It’s too late for me. But it’s not too late for the next veteran.”
What the institution did afterward
Black sued the United States over the White River Junction VA’s care, under the malpractice framework that governs claims against VA medicine. The government’s first move was not to answer the medicine; it was to argue the clock. As his attorney’s account records, the federal government sought dismissal on the ground that the administrative claim was untimely — that Black should have known he was a victim of malpractice on the date he was diagnosed with advanced-stage cancer, more than two years before he filed. A Vermont federal judge rejected that argument and denied the motion to dismiss, accepting that a patient who has been assured for years that he has a bowel disorder cannot be charged with knowing, on the day the truth surfaced, that the assurance was malpractice.
The case never reached a verdict. In the summer of 2021, the federal government settled: $3 million for Wesley Black, his wife Laura, and their infant son Ronan, with $500,000 placed in trust for Ronan. A Vermont federal judge approved the settlement. The case closed on October 19, 2021. The settlement was described in the reporting as first-of-its-kind — the first successful burn-pit malpractice settlement of its kind against the VA, a characterization the New York State Bar Association repeated when it honored Black’s attorney for pioneering the case, describing it as “the first successful suit dealing with the effects of burn pit exposure.”
Two qualifications belong on this page because accuracy is the whole of its authority. First: a settlement is not an admission. The government paid $3 million to resolve the case; it did not concede, and the settlement does not record, that burn-pit exposure caused Black’s cancer or that the VA admitted malpractice. Settlements are written to avoid exactly those concessions. Second, and it matters to how this site files him: Black’s was a misdiagnosis case, not a benefits-denial case. He was one of the rare Vermont burn-pit veterans whose conditions VA did service-connect. The institution that failed him was not the claims office. It was the clinic — the doctors who had his exposure in their own files and treated his cancer as a bowel complaint for four years. The VA sought comment on the AP’s reporting of his death; the record shows the request, not an answer.
Where it stands now
Wesley Black died at home in Hartford, Vermont, on November 7, 2021, surrounded by family and friends, nineteen days after his case closed. He was 36 years old. He left Laura and Ronan, a fire department that announced his passing as one of its own, and a cause he had spent his last years advancing with the specific intention that it arrive too late for him and in time for others.
It did arrive. Vermont’s burn-pit notification law — the measure Black testified for, requiring outreach to every Vermont veteran who served overseas — passed in his lifetime. The federal PACT Act, enacted in August 2022, nine months after his death, created the presumptive framework for burn-pit conditions that veterans of his deployments had sought for a generation; the generation of claims adjudicated one denial at a time was replaced, for the listed conditions and places, by presumption. Speaker Pelosi’s quotation of him on the House floor — “It’s too late for me. But it’s not too late for the next veteran” — stands in the Congressional Record as the epitaph he wrote for himself.
What the settlement established as precedent is narrower and, in its way, harder: that the VA’s clinical failure to consider a documented exposure can itself be the compensable injury, and that a veteran so failed is not barred by the calendar for having believed his doctors. The $3 million did not buy the Black family anything Black wanted. It bought Ronan a trust fund, and it put a price — the first price — on four years of a young man’s symptoms being explained away by the institution that knew what he had breathed.
The ledger
What has been done
- The federal government settled the Black family’s malpractice case for $3 million, approved by a Vermont federal judge; the case closed October 19, 2021, with $500,000 in trust for his son Ronan — reported as a first-of-its-kind burn-pit malpractice settlement.
- The government’s motion to dismiss the case as untimely was denied: a veteran assured he had irritable bowel syndrome would not be charged with knowing of the malpractice on the day the cancer was found.
- Vermont’s burn-pit notification law, for which Black testified, passed; the federal PACT Act followed in August 2022. Speaker Pelosi quoted his words — “It’s too late for me. But it’s not too late for the next veteran” — on the House floor.
- Black’s conditions were service-connected by the VA — he stands in this record as a misdiagnosis case, expressly not a benefits-denial case.
What has not been done
- No settlement is an admission: the government conceded neither causation nor malpractice in paying $3 million, and none is recorded.
- The four years of IBS treatment of a stage IV cancer were never the subject of a verdict or a public institutional accounting; the case ended, as such cases usually end, with payment in place of findings.
What is being sought
- What Black himself sought, in his testimony and in the words Congress preserved: that the next veteran with his exposure and his symptoms be looked at for what the exposure does — in time for it to matter.
Sources
- Associated Press, via Air Force Times, “Veteran exposed to toxic burn pit smoke dies of cancer after misdiagnosis lawsuit settlement,” November 10, 2021 — the 75-pound weight loss, the IBS diagnosis, the emergency-room colonoscopy finding stage IV cancer, the Dana-Farber physician’s 2018 letter, the $3 million settlement and October 19 closing, and his death at 36: https://www.airforcetimes.com/veterans/2021/11/10/veteran-exposed-to-toxic-burn-pit-smoke-dies-of-cancer-after-misdiagnosis-lawsuit-settlement/
- Military.com, November 11, 2021 — reporting on Black’s death and case.
- New York State Bar Association, “New York State Bar Association Honors Attorney for Pioneering Burn Pit Exposure Case,” January 10, 2023 — the malpractice theory (failure to consider burn-pit exposure in the diagnosis) and the “first successful suit dealing with the effects of burn pit exposure”: https://nysba.org/new-york-state-bar-association-honors-attorney-for-pioneering-burn-pit-exposure-case/
- The Perrone Firm, case account — the four years of treatment at White River Junction, the government’s untimeliness motion and its denial, and the $3 million settlement approved by a Vermont federal judge: https://www.theperronefirm.com/hartford-veteran-sues-over-missed-burn-pit-cancer-diagnosis-at-va
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed. Nothing here is re-hosted.