IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

The Law and the Directives

Risk Management does not run on discretion. It runs on documents — a statute, a set of regulations, and a shelf of VHA directives that say what must be reviewed, what must be disclosed, what must be sealed, and who decides. This page is that shelf, every item linked to its official source, so any reader can check our account against the government's own paper.

The seal: what the law keeps from you

38 U.S.C. § 5705 — Confidentiality of medical quality-assurance records (U.S. Code, Title 38). The foundation statute. Records created as part of a VA medical quality-assurance program “are confidential and privileged” and may be disclosed only as the statute’s own exceptions permit — a list that contains no exception for the patient, the family, a court order, or a discovery request. Willful disclosure outside those exceptions is a federal offense, punishable by fines of $5,000 (first offense) and $20,000 (subsequent offenses).

38 C.F.R. §§ 17.500–17.511 — Confidentiality of Healthcare Quality Assurance Review Records (Code of Federal Regulations, Title 38, Part 17). The regulations that implement § 5705: they define which quality-assurance review records are confidential and privileged, and the narrow conditions under which any of them may be released.

VHA Directive 1320 — Quality Management and Patient Safety Activities That Can Generate Confidential Records and Documents (VHA, July 10, 2020). The working list: root cause analyses, peer reviews, morbidity-and-mortality reviews, adverse-event and close-call reporting, and focused reviews are the activities designated to generate § 5705-confidential records — with the marking and securing duties that follow. Note the date problem the document carries on its own face: its recertification was due the last working day of July 2025, and no newer version is posted.

The program Congress ordered

38 U.S.C. § 7311 — Quality assurance (U.S. Code, Title 38). The other half of the structure: the same Congress that sealed the records also required the program — the Secretary “shall establish and conduct a comprehensive quality assurance program” for VHA care. Its companion, § 7311A, places quality management officers at the national, network, and facility levels.

VHA Directive 1050.01(1) — VHA Quality and Patient Safety Programs (VHA, March 24, 2023, as amended). Establishes VHA’s quality and patient safety programs under the Office of Quality and Patient Safety. This directive replaced the 2011 National Patient Safety Improvement Handbook — the older document still quoted around the internet no longer governs.

Disclosure: what they owe the family

VHA Directive 1004.08(1) — Disclosure of Adverse Events to Patients (VHA, October 31, 2018, as amended September 22, 2026). The disclosure directive. It sets three tiers — clinical, institutional, and large-scale disclosure — and provides that institutional disclosure, the formal process by which facility leaders tell a patient or family that an adverse event occurred, is generally initiated within 72 hours in cases of death or serious injury. The directive’s public listing names the responsible office (the National Center for Ethics in Health Care) and prints the reporting contact for the Medical-Legal Risk Management program: VHAMedicalLegalRiskM@va.gov. What the watchdogs found when they checked whether facilities actually do this is on the watchdog record page.

Peer review: judged by their own, behind the seal

VHA Directive 1190(1) — Peer Review for Quality Management (VHA, November 21, 2018, as amended July 19, 2024). The requirements for initiating, conducting, and documenting peer review of an individual clinician’s care. Each review is a § 5705-protected quality-management activity and must be designated as protected at the outset — which is why its conclusions are among the records a family will be refused. The publications listing directs questions to the Director, Risk Management Program.

The patient-safety machinery

VA National Center for Patient Safety (NCPS) (VHA, established 1999, Ann Arbor, Michigan). Runs VHA’s patient-safety program: the Root Cause Analysis process that examines how a system failed after a serious event, the confidential Patient Safety Information System, and Patient Safety Alerts and Advisories. Its FAQ describes the reporting system below.

Joint Patient Safety Reporting (JPSR) (Defense Health Agency / VHA). The single event-reporting system now shared by the military health system and VHA; VA adopted it in 2018. What gets reported into it is protected under § 5705 — the report goes in, and the family does not see it.

When a claim is filed

VHA Directive 1083(1) — Notification of Medical Malpractice (Tort) Claims to Involved Staff Members (VHA, February 9, 2023, as amended). When a malpractice tort claim lands, the facility director must notify every staff member identified in it — within 30 days of notice from the Office of General Counsel’s Torts Law Group — and report each named person’s employment status to OGC. The policy owner is the Office of Medical-Legal Risk Management. This directive is the paper trail of the moment a family’s claim becomes the institution’s risk file.

Claims Under the Federal Tort Claims Act — VA Office of General Counsel (VA OGC). The government’s own instructions: a claim is filed on Standard Form 95 (or in any writing carrying a detailed allegation, a sum certain, and a signature); it must be received within two years of the date the claim accrued; and it is adjudicated not by the hospital but by OGC’s regional tort offices (email: ogc.torts@va.gov). The implementing regulations are at 38 C.F.R. §§ 14.600–14.605.

The practical side of all of this — how to file the records request, and how the tort claim fits beside it — is the working tool on this site: Request the File: build your own Risk Management records request.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door